Authorities are increasing security measures at religious institutions on Staten Island following a series of incidents targeting Catholic churches. The enhanced precautions come after a recent string of disturbances, including acts of vandalism and violence.
Recent Incidents
Last Friday morning, Matthew Caffrey, 28, was arrested at St. Ann’s Church in Dongan Hills after allegedly storming the altar, disrupting a sermon, and fighting with two officers who attempted to intervene. Caffrey is now facing charges of assaulting an officer and resisting arrest.
Beyond the altercation at St. Ann’s, surveillance footage reportedly captured an individual smearing feces on the front door of St. Sylvester Church shortly before Christmas morning mass, according to Father Jacob Thumma. Police are also investigating four burglaries at Sacred Heart Church, where laptops, other items, and even candy were stolen. Two juveniles have been apprehended in connection with those crimes. A separate incident at St. Roch’s Church involved the theft of a towel after an individual entered through a window.
Community Response
Local leaders have expressed concern over the incidents. Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella stated, “People should feel safe in their sanctuary and be able to worship freely.” NYPD Staten Island Borough Commander Melissa Eger announced that community affairs officers have been dispatched to regularly visit all churches across the borough.
Religious leaders are suggesting a deeper issue may be at play. Father Thumma emphasized the need for increased investment in mental health resources to support families and provide timely intervention. The Richmond County District Attorney’s Office has indicated it is working to incorporate alternatives to incarceration into its approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
What actions are being taken to address the security concerns?
The NYPD is enhancing security at houses of worship on Staten Island, including increased police presence and regular visits from community affairs officers.
Have any arrests been made in connection with these incidents?
Yes, police say they have arrested the suspects in all of the reported incidents, including Matthew Caffrey and two juveniles linked to the burglaries at Sacred Heart Church.
What is being suggested as a long-term solution to prevent future incidents?
Religious leaders are calling for increased investment in mental health resources to support families and provide timely intervention before a crisis occurs.
It is possible that the increased police presence will deter further incidents in the short term. However, whether this heightened security will need to be maintained long-term will likely depend on whether the underlying causes of these disturbances are addressed.
Related reading