The Disturbing Rise of Grave Robbing: A Modern Problem Rooted in History

The recent arrest of Jonathan Christ Gerlach in Pennsylvania, and the discovery of over 100 human remains in his possession, isn’t an isolated incident. It’s a chilling symptom of a growing, and often overlooked, problem: grave robbing. While often associated with historical fiction and macabre tales, the desecration of burial sites is a surprisingly persistent crime, fueled by a complex mix of motives ranging from the opportunistic to the deeply disturbing.

From Antiquities to the Black Market: What Drives Grave Robbing?

Historically, grave robbing was driven by the demand for anatomical specimens for medical study – a dark chapter in the 18th and 19th centuries. Today, the motivations are more diverse. The theft of jewelry and valuables buried with the deceased, as seen in the Gerlach case, remains a significant driver. However, a disturbing trend is emerging: the collection of skeletal remains for occult practices, and a niche but active online market for human bones. According to a 2022 report by the FBI, while specific statistics on grave robbing are difficult to compile due to inconsistent reporting, investigations involving the illicit trade of human remains have increased by 20% in the last five years.

The Role of Online Marketplaces and Social Media

The internet has inadvertently become a facilitator for this illicit trade. Platforms like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, and even specialized online forums have been used to buy and sell human bones, often disguised as “antique medical specimens” or “historical artifacts.” A 2023 investigation by the Associated Press revealed numerous listings for human skulls and bones, with prices ranging from $50 to several hundred dollars. The anonymity offered by these platforms makes it difficult to track perpetrators and shut down these operations. Social media also plays a role, with groups dedicated to collecting and trading human remains operating in the shadows.

Why Historic Cemeteries Are Vulnerable

Older cemeteries, like the Mount Moriah Cemetery in Pennsylvania featured in this case, are particularly vulnerable. Many are poorly maintained, lack adequate security, and have deteriorating structures – making them easy targets for robbers. These cemeteries often contain valuable artifacts, including jewelry, coins, and even entire skeletons from prominent historical figures. The sheer size of some of these cemeteries also presents a challenge for law enforcement. Mount Moriah, for example, spans 160 acres, making comprehensive surveillance nearly impossible.

The Legal and Ethical Implications

Grave robbing carries significant legal consequences, including charges of desecration of a burial site, theft, and potentially, abuse of a corpse. However, the legal framework surrounding the protection of burial sites varies widely by state and country. Beyond the legal ramifications, the act is deeply unethical and causes immense distress to grieving families. The violation of a final resting place is a profound loss, and the thought of loved ones being disturbed and exploited is devastating.

The Impact on Forensic Science and Ancestral Research

Grave robbing also has implications for forensic science and ancestral research. The theft of remains can hinder investigations into historical crimes and prevent families from tracing their lineage. The damage to burial sites can also destroy valuable archaeological information. Furthermore, the illicit trade in human remains can contaminate legitimate scientific collections, making it difficult to authenticate artifacts and conduct accurate research.

Future Trends and Prevention Strategies

Experts predict that the problem of grave robbing will likely worsen in the coming years, driven by the increasing demand for human remains in niche markets and the continued accessibility of online platforms. Several strategies are needed to combat this trend:

  • Enhanced Security: Investing in improved security measures at cemeteries, including fencing, lighting, surveillance cameras, and regular patrols.
  • Stricter Regulations: Implementing stricter regulations on the sale and trade of human remains, both online and offline.
  • Increased Law Enforcement Training: Providing law enforcement with specialized training on how to investigate grave robbing cases and identify illicit trade networks.
  • Public Awareness Campaigns: Raising public awareness about the issue and the ethical implications of purchasing human remains.
  • Technological Solutions: Utilizing technologies like drone surveillance and ground-penetrating radar to detect and prevent unauthorized excavations.

Did you know?

In some cultures, ancestors are believed to protect their descendants. Grave robbing is seen not just as a crime, but as a spiritual offense with potentially severe consequences.

FAQ: Grave Robbing in the 21st Century

  • Is grave robbing common? While difficult to quantify, investigations into the illicit trade of human remains are increasing.
  • What are human remains used for? Occult practices, collection, and a niche market for “antique” specimens.
  • What are the penalties for grave robbing? Charges can include desecration of a burial site, theft, and abuse of a corpse, with penalties varying by jurisdiction.
  • How can cemeteries protect themselves? Enhanced security measures, including fencing, lighting, and surveillance.

Pro Tip: If you suspect grave robbing activity, report it immediately to your local law enforcement agency. Document any evidence, such as suspicious individuals or vehicles, and provide as much detail as possible.

Have you witnessed suspicious activity near a cemetery? Share your story with us here.

Explore more articles on historical crimes and forensic science here. Subscribe to our newsletter for updates on emerging trends in law enforcement and security.