Pirates’ Pursuit of Power: A Sign of Shifting MLB Offseason Strategies?
The Pittsburgh Pirates’ interest in free agent slugger Eugenio Suarez, as reported by Jason Mackey of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, isn’t just about filling a hole at third base. It’s a potential indicator of a broader trend: teams increasingly prioritizing raw power, even with its inherent risks, in a league evolving towards offensive extremes.
The Power Void and Pittsburgh’s Response
The Pirates finished dead last in MLB in home runs in 2025, a stark reality that prompted aggressive offseason moves. The additions of Brandon Lowe, Jhostynxon García, and Jake Mangum are steps in the right direction, but Suarez represents a different level of impact. His 49 home runs in 2025, despite a dip in production after a mid-season trade, highlight the kind of offensive ceiling Pittsburgh desperately needs. This isn’t a new phenomenon; the league-wide emphasis on launch angle and exit velocity has driven up home run totals for years. However, teams are now more willing to accept the accompanying strikeouts and lower batting averages if the power potential is significant.
Consider the recent success of players like Pete Alonso (New York Mets) and Kyle Schwarber (formerly with the Phillies). Both consistently rank among the league leaders in home runs, despite having flaws in their overall offensive profiles. Their ability to change a game with one swing has proven invaluable, and teams are actively seeking similar players.
The Cost of Power: Balancing Risk and Reward
Suarez’s case exemplifies this trade-off. While his power is undeniable – finishing fifth in MLB in home runs and tenth in slugging percentage – his .228 batting average and high strikeout rate are red flags. The Pirates’ willingness to even consider a multi-year deal for Suarez, especially given their historically conservative spending habits (highlighted by the Liriano and O’Hearn contracts), suggests a shift in philosophy. They’re signaling a willingness to take calculated risks to address their most glaring offensive weakness.
This trend is also reflected in the projections for Suarez’s contract. MLB Trade Rumors estimates a three-year, $63MM deal, a significant sum for a player with his profile. However, the scarcity of true power hitters is driving up the market value, even for players with clear limitations.
Did you know? The average MLB home run rate has increased by over 20% in the last decade, demonstrating the league’s growing emphasis on power hitting.
The Competitive Landscape and the Bregman Effect
The limited competition for Suarez – reportedly the Mariners, Red Sox, and Cubs – is intriguing. The fact that several teams are also pursuing Alex Bregman suggests a bifurcated market: a high-end tier for well-rounded stars and a separate tier for power-first players. The Pirates’ failed pursuit of Kazuma Okamoto, who signed with the Blue Jays, further underscores their focus on power. Okamoto, like Suarez, offered significant offensive upside, and his departure likely intensified Pittsburgh’s interest in the veteran slugger.
The Mariners’ situation is particularly interesting. Their existing third base options may limit their pursuit of Suarez specifically, indicating they’re prioritizing versatility over pure power. This highlights another emerging trend: teams valuing players who can contribute in multiple ways, even if it means sacrificing some offensive potential.
The Future of Offense: What’s Next?
We can expect to see more teams prioritize power hitting in the coming years, even if it means accepting lower batting averages and higher strikeout rates. Advanced analytics have demonstrated the value of home runs and extra-base hits, and teams are increasingly willing to build their offenses around players who can consistently deliver those results. This doesn’t mean that traditional hitting skills are becoming obsolete, but they are being devalued relative to power.
Pro Tip: When evaluating free agent hitters, focus on metrics like Isolated Power (ISO) and Hard Hit Rate, as these provide a better indication of a player’s offensive potential than traditional stats like batting average.
FAQ
Q: Will the Pirates actually sign Eugenio Suarez?
A: It’s uncertain. While they have expressed interest, the bidding could drive up the price beyond their comfort level.
Q: Is power hitting the only thing that matters in baseball?
A: No, but it’s becoming increasingly important. Teams still value on-base percentage, speed, and defense, but power is a key component of a successful offense.
Q: What is Isolated Power (ISO)?
A: ISO is a statistic that measures a hitter’s power, calculated as (Slugging Percentage – Batting Average). A higher ISO indicates more power.
Q: How does PNC Park affect a hitter’s power numbers?
A: PNC Park is generally considered a pitcher-friendly ballpark, meaning it suppresses offensive production. Suarez’s decline after being traded to Seattle, another pitcher-friendly park, is a concern for the Pirates.
Want to stay up-to-date on the latest MLB news and analysis? Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive insights and expert opinions!
