A probationary constable injured during Sunday’s terrorist attack at Bondi Beach has lost the sight in one eye, as scrutiny intensifies regarding police presence and experience at the event. Jack Hibbert, 22, sustained two gunshot wounds – one to the head and one to the shoulder – while on duty patrolling the Hanukkah celebration.
Injuries and Response
According to a family statement, Hibbert, who joined the police force just four months ago, underwent multiple surgeries after being taken to intensive care. Despite surviving, he has lost vision in one eye and faces a lengthy recovery with further surgeries anticipated. Another officer, Constable Scott Dyson, who has been with the eastern suburbs police area command for 18 months, was also injured in the attack and remains in critical but stable condition after undergoing additional surgery.
NSW Premier Chris Minns stated on Wednesday that at least three officers were patrolling the park where the shooting occurred. He also noted that NSW police collaborated closely with the Community Security Group (CSG), a private security initiative for the Jewish community, to provide security for Hanukkah events in Bondi, North Bondi, and Dover Heights. Approximately 20 NSW police officers were reportedly on duty in the Bondi area, including two detectives.
Questions Raised About Police Resourcing
The adequacy of police resourcing at the event has come under question. Former federal minister Josh Frydenberg voiced concerns on Wednesday, asking how only three officers were present given the large crowd – estimated at around 1,000 people – and the “heightened threat environment.” NSW opposition leader Kellie Sloane echoed these concerns, emphasizing the need to understand what more could have been done to protect attendees.
Premier Minns defended the actions of the officers, stating they acted “with bravery and integrity” and were responsible for neutralizing the attackers. However, the incident has prompted a review of police policies and resources.
Dr. Vince Hurley, a lecturer in criminology and former NSW police officer with 29 years of experience, suggested that even with increased police presence, the chaotic nature of the attack may have yielded similar results. He stated that officers arriving on the scene would have been “initially as shocked as the punters” and faced an “impossible mandate” given the crowded conditions.
Potential Next Steps
NSW Police Commissioner Mal Lanyon has indicated the force will review its policies and resources in light of the attack. It is likely that the review will consider whether front-line officers should have access to more powerful firearms, a practice that has historically been limited due to concerns about escalation and public safety. A debate over the appropriate level of force and the balance between officer safety and public safety could follow. Further investigation into the events leading up to the attack and the response of law enforcement is also anticipated.
Frequently Asked Questions
What injuries did the police officers sustain?
Constable Jack Hibbert sustained two gunshot wounds – one to the head and one to the shoulder – resulting in the loss of sight in one eye. Constable Scott Dyson was also injured and remains in critical but stable condition after undergoing further surgery.
How many police officers were present at the Hanukkah celebration?
NSW Premier Chris Minns stated that at least three officers were patrolling the park where the shooting took place, with around 20 officers on duty in the Bondi area overall, including two detectives.
What is the Community Security Group (CSG)?
The CSG is a private security initiative for the Jewish community, and NSW police reportedly worked closely with them regarding security for Hanukkah events in the Bondi area.
As the investigation continues and the injured officers begin their long road to recovery, what steps can communities and law enforcement take to better prepare for and respond to potential threats at public gatherings?
