Private Equity Fraud Case Signals Increased Scrutiny of Deal Valuations
US prosecutors have charged two former Mobileum executives with fraud, alleging they artificially inflated the company’s financial results prior to its $915 million sale to HIG Capital in 2022. This case, involving ex-CFO Andrew Warner and former chief of delivery operations Kishore Vangipuram, marks a rare instance of criminal charges stemming from a private equity deal and points to a potential shift towards greater oversight of valuations in the industry.
The Allegations: Fabricated Revenue and Misleading Metrics
According to the indictment, Warner and Vangipuram allegedly “manufactured millions of dollars in imaginary revenue” by manipulating the accounting system. Specifically, they are accused of inflating reported hours worked or reducing estimated project timelines to prematurely recognize revenue. Prosecutors claim the pair sought to maximize the sale price and, their personal proceeds – Warner receiving $5.2 million and Vangipuram $5.5 million from the deal.
The scheme reportedly involved requesting a client for a “favour” to invoice additional amounts without expectation of payment, artificially boosting revenue figures. Prosecutors also allege that after the sale, Vangipuram cautioned a colleague against email correspondence regarding invoicing, fearing it could lead to legal trouble. A potential buyer had previously backed away from a deal due to concerns about Mobileum’s financial transparency.
A Civil War Within Private Equity
This criminal case unfolds alongside a parallel civil dispute. HIG Capital has filed a lawsuit against Audax, the previous owner of Mobileum, alleging accounting fraud inflated the sale price. Audax has countersued HIG, citing corporate governance failures after the acquisition. The indictment confirms the fraud HIG alleged in its civil lawsuit.
Bankruptcy and the Aftermath
Mobileum filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2024, completing its reorganization later that year. The timing suggests the alleged financial manipulations were ultimately unsustainable, leading to the company’s financial distress. The “cycle of falsification” continued until 2024, according to prosecutors.
What This Means for the Future of Private Equity
The Mobileum case isn’t an isolated incident. It reflects a growing concern about the accuracy of financial reporting within the private equity sector, particularly in an environment where valuations have soared and deal-making has been aggressive.
Increased Regulatory Scrutiny
Jay Clayton, the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, previously chaired the private markets group at Apollo Global Management. His interest in scrutinizing private market valuations signals a potential increase in regulatory oversight. Expect to witness more investigations into financial practices at private equity-owned companies.
Due Diligence Under the Microscope
The case highlights the critical importance of thorough due diligence. The fact that a potential buyer previously backed out due to inadequate financial information underscores the risks of relying solely on management representations. Future deals will likely involve more rigorous independent verification of financial data.
Focus on Revenue Recognition
The allegations center on manipulating revenue recognition practices. Companies will need to ensure strict adherence to accounting standards, particularly regarding revenue recognition over time. Expect increased scrutiny of unbilled revenue and the justification for recognizing it.
The Rise of Forensic Accounting
Demand for forensic accounting services is likely to increase as private equity firms seek to proactively identify and mitigate financial risks. These specialists can uncover irregularities and provide assurance regarding the accuracy of financial reporting.
FAQ
What are the charges against Warner and Vangipuram? They face charges of conspiracy to commit securities and wire fraud, as well as separate counts of securities fraud and wire fraud.
Were Audax or HIG accused of wrongdoing? The indictment does not name either Audax or HIG, and neither group has been accused of wrongdoing.
What is the significance of this case? It’s a rare instance of criminal charges in a private equity deal, signaling increased scrutiny of valuations and financial reporting.
What happened with Mobileum after the sale? Mobileum filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2024 and completed a reorganization.
Did you know? The alleged scheme involved invoicing a client nearly €12 million but receiving only €40,000 in payment.
Pro Tip: Private equity firms should prioritize independent verification of financial data during due diligence to mitigate risks.
Stay informed about the latest developments in private equity and financial regulation. Explore more articles on our website or subscribe to our newsletter for regular updates.
