Why India‑Russia Ties Are Stuck on a Plateau – And What Could Change the Game
When President Vladimir Putin landed in New Delhi, the photo‑ops were unmistakable: a warm handshake, a “special and privileged” partnership proclaimed in the joint statement, and a headline‑grabbing $2 billion nuclear‑submarine lease. Yet beneath the pomp, analysts see a relationship that has stalled—and the reasons are deeper than diplomatic etiquette.
Key Friction Points Holding Back Deeper Integration
- Defense procurement woes: Delayed deliveries of S‑400 systems and unreliable spare‑part supply chains have eroded Indian confidence.
- Trade imbalance: India buys Russian oil, but Russian purchases of Indian goods remain negligible, widening the deficit.
- Sanctions pressure: Payments in dollars are increasingly blocked, while rupee‑based settlements are still a pipe dream.
- People‑to‑people concerns: Reports of Indian nationals being funneled into the Ukraine front line have soured migration talks.
Future Trends: Where the Partnership Could Pivot
1. A Shift Toward “Strategic”, Not “Operational,” Defence Ties
While the leased Akula‑class submarine will only serve training purposes, it could spark a knowledge‑transfer program for India’s own under‑water fleet. Expect joint research labs and simulation centers to grow, especially as India seeks to modernise its navy without committing to full‑scale purchases.
Did you know? India’s Naval Aviation Command plans to acquire at least 30 new maritime patrol aircraft by 2028, many of which could be co‑developed with Russian manufacturers under a “technology‑sharing” umbrella.
2. Energy Cooperation in a Low‑Carbon World
With global oil demand plateauing, both capitals are eyeing hydrogen and nuclear power as the next frontier. The 2023 International Energy Agency forecast predicts that by 2030, hydrogen could account for 5 % of total global energy consumption—an arena where Russia has abundant expertise and India has ambitious decarbonisation targets.
External data: IEA’s Hydrogen Roadmap (2023) highlights Russia’s potential as a low‑cost hydrogen exporter, while India’s National Hydrogen Mission aims for 5 GW of electrolyzer capacity by 2030.
3. Diversifying Trade Beyond Crude Oil
India is already moving its pharma and agritech exports toward new markets, but a mutual “non‑tariff barrier reduction” pact could open Russian wheat to Indian food‑processing firms and vice‑versa for Indian spices. Negotiators are reportedly drafting a “farm‑goods corridor” that could shave 12 % off current Russian import costs.
4. Geopolitical Hedging and the Multipolar Push
Both capitals share a desire to counterbalance China’s growing sway in Asia. As the United States deepens its “Indo‑Pacific” engagement, India leverages Russia to remind Washington that a “multipolar Asia” is still viable. Expect joint statements at future Shangri‑La Dialogue meetings that stress strategic autonomy and regional balance.
Pro tip: Watch the upcoming Shangri‑La Dialogue coverage for the latest diplomatic choreography between New Delhi, Moscow, and Washington.
What This Means for Businesses and Policymakers
- Investors should monitor Russian energy‑transition projects for early‑stage joint‑venture opportunities.
- Exporters can capitalize on India’s push for reduced non‑tariff barriers by aligning product standards with Russian regulations.
- Defense contractors may pivot toward “service‑only” models—training, maintenance, and digital simulators—rather than full equipment sales.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Will India ever buy a Russian nuclear submarine outright?
- No. The current lease is limited to training and is unlikely to convert into a purchase given ongoing delivery delays and financial constraints.
- How do Western sanctions affect India‑Russia trade?
- Sanctions restrict dollar‑based transactions and limit access to international financing, forcing both sides to seek alternative payment mechanisms that are still under development.
- Is the India‑Russia partnership a counterbalance to China?
- Yes. Both nations use the bilateral relationship to signal strategic independence and to push for a “multipolar world” that dilutes China’s regional dominance.
- What sectors offer the most growth potential?
- Energy transition (hydrogen, nuclear), defense training services, and agricultural‑goods trade are the leading growth avenues.
What’s Next?
The partnership may never reach the lofty “$100 billion trade” goal touted in past summits, but strategic nuances are evolving. The real test will be whether both capitals can translate political warmth into tangible, resilient projects that withstand sanctions, supply‑chain shocks, and shifting global alliances.
Let’s keep the conversation going. Share your thoughts below, explore our deep‑dive report on economic ties, and subscribe to our newsletter for weekly insights on Indo‑Pacific geopolitics.
