Relativity Disrupts Triple Bond Rules in Heavy Elements

"The notion that relativity plays a significant role in heavy elements has existed since the 1970s," remarked Lai-Sheng Wang, a professor of chemistry at Brown University.

Chemists at the university have now provided direct experimental evidence that triple bonds in heavy elements do not follow standard chemical bonding rules taught in classrooms, according to a study published in the journal Science.

Einstein’s Relativity Alters Bonding

The research challenges a foundational principle of chemistry regarding how atoms share electrons. In standard models, a triple bond is defined by one sigma bond and two pi bonds. The sigma bond typically forms through a direct, head-on overlap of electron orbitals, while pi bonds form through side-by-side overlaps.

Heavy elements, however, possess large nuclei with many protons that pull nearby electrons to a significant fraction of the speed of light. At these velocities, Einstein’s theory of relativity becomes a factor in atomic structure. This leads to spin-orbit coupling, where an electron’s spin and its orbital motion become linked.

Smearing the Bonding Boundary

The study found that this relativistic effect disrupts the traditional distinction between bond types. "The boundary between a sigma bond and a pi bond is now sort of smeared," Wang said. "Although three bonds are present, they can no longer be strictly categorized as sigma or pi."

To observe this, researchers Deniz Kahraman and Jie Hui created molecules containing carbon and bismuth. Bismuth is a heavy metallic element located next to lead on the periodic table, making it an ideal candidate to test the limits of conventional bonding models.

Spectroscopic Evidence in Bismuth

The team used photoelectron spectroscopy to examine the molecules at temperatures near absolute zero. By hitting the molecules with laser light, they measured the energy required to eject electrons, which revealed the underlying electronic structure.

Instead of the predicted configuration of one sigma bond and two pi bonds, the carbon-bismuth connections showed a hybrid structure consisting of one pi bond and two hybrid sigma-pi bonds. The findings provide direct experimental confirmation of these relativistic effects in triple bonding.

Implications for Quantum Materials

The discovery may influence future chemistry textbooks as research into heavy element interactions grows. Beyond fundamental theory, the results could impact the development of new technologies.

Bismuth is currently being researched as a potential non-toxic alternative to lead in next-generation solar cells. The findings may also aid researchers working in quantum computing and quantum materials, where controlling electron behavior is essential for device performance. The research was supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation under grant CHE-2403841 and the U.S. Department of Energy under grant DE-SC0008501.

Questions About Relativistic Chemistry

Why do heavy elements behave differently than lighter ones?
Heavy elements have a high number of protons that create strong electrical attractions. These forces accelerate electrons to speeds where relativistic effects, such as spin-orbit coupling, significantly alter electron behavior and bonding geometry.

How was the bonding structure observed?
Researchers used photoelectron spectroscopy on carbon-bismuth molecules cooled to near absolute zero. By measuring the energy of electrons ejected by laser light, they determined the specific electronic arrangement of the bonds.

This investigation builds on a career of discovery for Lai-Sheng Wang, who was born in 1961 and has long focused on the fundamental behaviors of nanoclusters. Before his tenure at Brown University, Wang pioneered methods for studying free multiply-charged anions in the gas phase and is widely recognized for his work identifying unique atomic structures, including atomic gold pyramids and planar boron clusters.

Throughout his career, he has authored over 530 scientific articles and received numerous honors for his contributions to molecular spectroscopy, including the 2014 Earle K. Plyler Prize and the 2021 E. Bright Wilson Award.

What are the practical applications of this research?
A more accurate understanding of heavy-element bonding could improve the development of quantum materials and lead to the creation of non-toxic solar cells, as bismuth is being explored as an alternative to lead in those technologies.