Rutgers Beats Penn State 25-24 on Last-Second Lateral, 2-Point Conversion

Rutgers, a 3-8 underdog, upset 6-5 Penn State 25-24 on a last-second lateral and 2-point conversion.

Rutgers secured a 25-24 upset victory over Penn State on Saturday at Beaver Stadium, ending a 38-year losing streak in the series.

Rutgers Wins With Final Lateral

Down 24-17 with six seconds remaining from the two-yard line, Rutgers quarterback AJ Surace completed a short pass to running back Antwan Raymond. As defenders swarmed and the clock expired, Raymond lateraled the ball backward to wide receiver Ben Black III, who walked into the end zone untouched, according to Rutgers University Athletics.

Instead of playing for overtime, head coach Greg Schiano sent the offense back out for a two-point conversion. Surace found running back Clay Thevenin open on a swing pass to the right for the game-winning score, as reported by Yahoo Sports.

First Win Since 1988

The result marked the first time the Scarlet Knights defeated Penn State since 1988, snapping an 18-game skid against their regional rivals. Rutgers entered the matchup as more than four-touchdown underdogs after losing four straight games, according to New York Post.

The visitors also captured their first-ever Big Ten victory in the series, having gone 0-11 against the Nittany Lions since joining the conference in 2014.

Photo: Yahoo

“That was something special,” Schiano said, according to ESPN. “I’m really, really proud of this team, their faith, their belief in what we do. It would have been easy to say, ‘this isn’t our year,’ and ‘let’s get to next year.’ But there hasn’t been any of that the whole season.”

Penn State Loses Lead

Penn State controlled the early portion of the contest, building a 16-0 lead in the second quarter behind a 56-yard touchdown run from Cam Wallace, a safety, and a 17-yard scoring pass from Rocco Becht to Chase Sowell.

The Nittany Lions later extended their advantage to 24-10 in the third quarter when Becht scored on a 6-yard keeper and caught a two-point conversion pass from tight end Benjamin Brahmer, as detailed by Pennlive.

Rutgers chipped away by mounting a 19-play, 75-yard drive that consumed 9 minutes and 38 seconds, culminating in a 13-yard touchdown run by Raymond with 10:19 remaining.

Rutgers Walks it Off With the Two-Point Conversion vs Penn State — Big Ten Football

Raymond finished the evening with 101 rushing yards and two touchdowns on 23 carries, while Surace threw for 178 yards despite playing through three fractured ribs, according to The Morning Call.

“I didn’t have the team prepared to play its best football game, senior day, the end of the season, and that really hurts me,” Campbell said, according to The New York Times.

Coaches and Players React

Following the final whistle, Penn State head coach Matt Campbell told reporters that his team could not afford to leave the outcome to chance on the game’s decisive final sequence. Linebacker Tony Rojas described the surreal ending as a gut-wrenching moment that left players standing in total awe on the field, while offensive lineman Anthony Donkoh appeared completely stunned and exhausted in the post-game interview room.

Photo: The Morning Call

Greg Schiano praised his quarterback’s toughness by calling the performance the most gutsy display he had ever witnessed from a competitive athlete. The Rutgers head coach also reflected on the rich history of the venue, noting that while he holds many special memories at Beaver Stadium, none of them surpass the magnitude of this historic victory.

“There's a lot of history in this building, personally. … It was a lot of thought driving in here last night. I have a lot of special memories here, but I don't know if any of them are more special than this,” Schiano said.

Antwan Raymond Takes it Home vs Penn State — Big Ten Football

Game Draws 106,200 Fans to Beaver Stadium

The game unfolded in front of an announced attendance of 106,200 spectators at Beaver Stadium. Entering the contest, the Nittany Lions held an all-time series advantage of 33 wins to just two losses against their regional opponents.

Last season, Penn State defeated Rutgers by a score of 40-36 in Piscataway, New Jersey. The broadcast was televised nationally on FS1 with commentary from Noah Reed and Petros Papadakis, while the Penn State Radio Network broadcast featured the commentary team of Steve Jones, Jack Ham, and Brian Tripp.

Rutgers at Penn State | Highlights | Big Ten Football — Big Ten Football

Both squads entered the penultimate week of the regular season looking for a late-year spark. The Scarlet Knights arrived in State College holding a 3-8 overall record and a 2-6 mark in Big Ten play, while the Nittany Lions stood at 6-5 overall and 3-5 in conference action.

Rutgers athletic director Keli Zinn announced earlier in the month that Schiano will return for the 2027 campaign to lead the program for his 19th total season, marking his eighth consecutive year during his second stint at the helm in Piscataway.

Thevenin PSU
Photo: Rutgers University Athletics

The Nittany Lions played the matchup shorthanded, missing several key contributors due to injury, including wide receiver Koby Howard, defensive end Max Granville, linebacker Alex Tatsch, and defensive end Caleb Bacon. During the first quarter, running back James Peoples sustained a lower left leg injury after ripping off a 15-yard run and had to be carried off the field without being able to put any weight on his leg.

Offensively, Penn State struggled on third downs during the second half as the visiting defense locked down, while the Nittany Lions continued a season-long trend of being plagued by turnovers, including fumbles in the pocket and backfield miscues that halted promising drives.

Penn State-Rutgers post-game: Well, THAT just happened — Penn State on PennLive

Rutgers secured a historic victory inside Beaver Stadium, an arena featuring an official seating capacity of 106,572 that ranks as the second-largest venue in the Western Hemisphere. Entering the matchup as heavy underdogs, the Scarlet Knights overcame long odds to conquer one of the most formidable atmospheres in collegiate athletics.

Recognized widely as one of the toughest playing environments for visiting programs, the arena regularly challenges opponents with its massive crowds and hostile conditions, making an upset win on the road exceptionally significant for any visiting team.

Following the final whistle, the Scarlet Knights celebrated their improbable comeback victory on the road before shifting their focus to their regular-season finale. Rutgers will host Michigan State next Saturday, while Penn State will travel on the road to face Maryland.