Pitchfork founder Ryan Schreiber is detailing his experiences selling the music website to Condé Nast in 2015, describing the corporate environment under Anna Wintour as cold and restrictive.
In his new memoir, Weird Era: How Pitchfork Changed Music Forever, Schreiber recounts the shift from the site’s independent roots to its integration into a major media conglomerate, The Guardian reported.
- Pitchfork launched in 1995 as Turntable before being renamed and gaining influence as a music criticism publication, according to The Guardian.
- Schreiber resigned from the company in 2018, three years after the acquisition by Condé Nast, The Guardian reported.
Schreiber, who founded the site in 1995, writes that he initially hoped the acquisition would provide financial stability while allowing the publication to retain creative control. However, he describes the reality of the partnership as disillusioning, citing an ad team he viewed as ill-suited for the brand and a corporate culture he found lacking in empathy.
Schreiber’s early inspiration for the platform came from a desire to emulate the DIY spirit and humor of a pop culture zine called Cake, as well as the righteous snark found in British publications like Melody Maker and NME. He said that he resonated with a sentiment displayed by Kurt Cobain on a Rolling Stone cover featuring a shirt that read, “Corporate magazines still suck.”

“Zine culture made me feel that I could do this in a way that doesn’t have to be from a formally educated, journalism degree background,” Schreiber said. “When I got online, I was like, ‘I could literally just start doing this by myself.’”
He also said that his perspective on music criticism evolved over time, influenced by critic Kelefa Sanneh’s 2004 essay, The Rap Against Rockism, which examined the prejudices inherent in music snobbery toward pop and R&B. “The culture around me changed very much as well,” he said.
“Seeing it at hand was as ugly, if not maybe a little bit uglier than I anticipated,” Schreiber said of Wintour’s behavior, telling The Guardian that he felt disregarded under her management. He characterized the environment at Condé Nast headquarters as one where employees were treated as “just a cog in a broader machine,” noting that he felt there was “no warmth whatsoever.”
The memoir also addresses Schreiber’s personal journey, including coming out as gay in his 40s after leaving the publication. He writes that he previously suppressed aspects of his identity, fearing that being an out gay man would be incompatible with his public reputation as the face of Pitchfork.
Ryan Schreiber launched Pitchfork in 1996 as a bedroom zine from his home in Victoria, Minnesota, drawing inspiration from fanzine culture. By 2014, the site had expanded significantly, reaching approximately 6.2 million monthly unique visitors.
Driven by a desire for financial stability, Schreiber sold the publication to Condé Nast in 2015. However, the corporate transition proved difficult; he eventually resigned from the company in 2019, four years after the acquisition, following a period of disillusionment with the restrictive culture at the new headquarters.
Schreiber now views his decision to sell the company as a moment to process with hindsight. Reflecting on the final day of his tenure, he told The Guardian, “I’ve looked back and gone, ‘What if we’d held on? What if we tried to make some of these difficult decisions ourselves that were ultimately made for us?’”
Worth a look