Sean Zak Argues Golf Rules Need Simplification

In a recent column for MyGolfSpy, Sean Zak argues that the current Rules of Golf are overly complex and should be condensed from their current 244-page length to just 10 pages.

Zak contends that the governing bodies have made progress in simplifying the rules, but he believes there is significant room for further reduction.

The debate over the rulebook was sparked by a reader inquiry from John Herman, who asked, “Why is it that the rules of golf are explained in a manner where you need a masters degree to understand them?” Zak agrees with the sentiment, noting that the current volume of regulations often makes it difficult for players to find clear, consistent guidance for common situations on the course.

The Fairway Divot Controversy

One of the most contentious topics raised by readers is whether players should receive free relief from fairway divots. While some, such as Gale Nicely, argue that golfers should not be penalized for an otherwise good shot, Zak maintains that playing the ball as it lies is fundamental to the sport.

Zak points out that establishing a workable definition of a “fresh” divot is nearly impossible across different types of courses. He says that in a 20-foot circle at a local municipal course, multiple lies could be interpreted differently, making it difficult for two groups to reach the same decision.

As a result, he remains opposed to granting free relief, arguing that the unpredictability of a lie is part of the game.

Zak identifies white stakes as his least favorite rule in golf, specifically criticizing the severity of the stroke-and-distance penalty. He argues that the requirement to walk back to the tee is particularly problematic on courses where housing developments border both sides of a fairway.

Instead of the current penalty, Zak suggests implementing a one-stroke option near where the ball went out of bounds, which would result in the player hitting their third shot.

While reader Dan Salmon pushed back on this, noting that being able to see a ball out of bounds does not change the fact that it is out of play, Zak maintains that the current rule often feels gimmicky rather than fair.

Practical Adjustments for Pace of Play

The column also highlights support for Model Local Rule B-3, which allows a provisional ball to be played for a ball that might be in a penalty area. Reader Paula Fairley described the rule as a “great time saver,” a position Zak supports as a practical way to keep groups moving on the course.

Regarding the use of the flagstick on the green, Zak notes that while some players prefer to leave it in for aiming purposes, he still chooses to remove it himself. He remains skeptical that leaving the flagstick in significantly improves the pace of play, but he sees no reason to reinstate a penalty for the practice.

Red and Yellow Stakes Address Course Design Needs

Why are there different rules for red and yellow penalty areas?
Red and yellow stakes allow courses to account for how water hazards come into play. According to Zak, yellow stakes are often used where lateral relief would be inappropriate, such as on island greens like No. 17 at TPC Sawgrass, where dropping near the green would fundamentally alter the hole’s design.

Should professional golfers be allowed to wear shorts?
Zak argues that there is no functional reason to mandate pants during regular Tour events, especially in hot weather. However, he maintains that traditional attire should remain the standard for major championships like the Masters and The Open.

Sean Zak is a senior writer at GOLF.com who has made the annual Open Championship pilgrimage for the last four years. A 7.8-handicap with a driver swing speed around 110-112 mph, he lives next to a driving range and lists tennis as his favorite non-golf hobby.

How much of the rulebook would be cut?
Zak states that if it were up to him, he would cut the current 244-page rulebook down to 10 pages. He says that the governing bodies have already made efforts to simplify the language, but he continues to look for ways to make the rules more accessible for all golfers.