Robert Donovan, a senior project manager facing a performance improvement plan after raising salary delays, has been awarded €67,500 by the Workplace Relations Commission for constructive dismissal against Indeff Ltd.
Tribunal Finds Performance Improvement Plan Was Exit Strategy
Adjudicator Lefre de Burgh ruled that the performance improvement plan was an “orchestrated response with exit in mind” following Robert Donovan’s complaints about persistent salary delays. Published on Wednesday, the Workplace Relations Commission decision granted Donovan a full year’s salary for loss of earnings. Indeff Ltd, the Irish subsidiary of a Belgian-headquartered industrial automation multinational, did not attend the hearing after failing to secure an adjournment.
Donovan stated that household expenses, mortgage payments, car loans, and school fees left him “overdrawn very, very regularly” due to irregular paychecks. Represented by barrister Lorna Madden and instructed by O’Donoghue and Associates Solicitors, Donovan submitted that he emailed his employer on October 2nd, 2023, to state he was only paid on time “once in the past seven months.”
Escalation and Resignation at Indeff Ltd
The day after his complaint, a senior manager identified as “BR” in the tribunal decision told Donovan his email was “unacceptable.” BR directed him to attend a meeting the following week with the head of the Irish operation and the company’s head of human resources. At that meeting, management informed Donovan he was being placed on a performance improvement plan.
Donovan told the adjudicator there was “no basis” for the measure, asserting that his work performance was “blowing the doors off the hinges” and that no complaints had been made against him. He resigned on the spot. Adjudicator de Burgh accepted this evidence, noting that the frequent delays, short payments, and missed wages constituted a clear repudiation of the employment contract.
Robert Donovan awarded sixty-seven thousand euros after resigning from Indeff Ltd
What was the financial award given to Robert Donovan?
Robert Donovan was awarded €67,500, representing a year’s salary for loss of earnings.
Which company was named in the Workplace Relations Commission decision?
Indeff Ltd, the Irish arm of a Belgian-headquartered industrial automation multinational, was the respondent in the case.
Why did the employee resign?
Donovan resigned after being placed on a performance improvement plan immediately following a formal complaint about his salary being paid late, short, or missed entirely.
Did the employer attend the tribunal hearing?
No, Indeff Ltd did not attend after failing to establish entitlement to an adjournment they had requested.
Related reading