Shopping malls across South Africa are bracing for a transitional period as long-term lease agreements will no longer guarantee exclusive grocery retail space for Shoprite, Pick n Pay, and SPAR, according to Newsday.
These grocery retailers have historically prevented competing stores from opening in the same shopping centres through exclusivity clauses. From 1 January 2027, grocery retailers will not be allowed to enter into new exclusive lease agreements, and all existing arrangements must be terminated by 31 December 2026.
The changes stem from the Competition Commission’s Grocery Retail Market Inquiry, which was published in December 2019. The inquiry found that exclusive lease agreements restricted competition, limited consumer choice, and made it difficult for smaller and emerging retailers to enter the market.
Following the inquiry, the commission reached consent agreements with Shoprite, Pick n Pay, and SPAR, which the Competition Tribunal confirmed as legally binding orders.
Impact on major retailers and landlords
Siyabulela Makunga, spokesperson for the Competition Commission, verified that the December 2026 deadline marks the termination point for all remaining grocery exclusivity contracts. He said that the restrictions applied to Shoprite, Pick n Pay, and SPAR, while Woolworths and Food Lover’s Market were unaffected because they did not hold exclusive leases.
“It affects all landlords with grocery exclusivity clauses, though many wanted them scrapped anyway,” Makunga told Newsday.
The inquiry revealed that exclusivity agreements protected established supermarket groups, entrenched their positions in shopping centres, and limited opportunities for other businesses. Shoprite concluded its consent agreement first, confirmed by the Competition Tribunal in October 2020. Pick n Pay followed in June 2021, and SPAR finalized its agreement in 2023.
Under these agreements, retailers had to stop enforcing exclusivity clauses against small and medium-sized enterprises and grocery stores owned by historically disadvantaged people.
New grocery choices for shoppers
SPAR’s agreement also committed to ending the enforcement of exclusivity provisions against speciality stores and small businesses, subject to exceptions like a 12-month exclusion for competing franchisees.
Growthpoint head of retail asset management Gavin Jones said landlords had anticipated the shift and were adjusting tenant mixes. Shopping centres are already introducing different retailers and renewing leases without exclusivity clauses, according to Jones.
“The change has created opportunities to introduce a second or third supermarket into larger centres,” Jones told Newsday.
“This pairing of mainstream grocers with value-focused retailers such as Shoprite and Boxer will serve different customer segments and give shoppers greater choice,” Jones said.
However, Jones said that not every shopping centre would immediately gain more retailers. Available space, centre size, and commercial decisions will determine where new grocery stores open.
Questions about retail lease changes
Why are exclusive grocery leases ending in South Africa?
The Competition Commission found during its 2019 market inquiry that exclusive leases restricted competition, limited consumer choice, and blocked smaller businesses from entering high-foot-traffic shopping centres.
When must all exclusive lease agreements terminate?
All existing grocery exclusivity arrangements must be terminated by 31 December 2026, and retailers are prohibited from entering into new exclusive agreements from 1 January 2027.
Established under the Competition Act of 1998, the Competition Commission began operations on 1 September 1999 as South Africa’s official anti-trust regulator. It forms part of the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition and holds the power to block mergers that would reduce competition or limit consumer choice.
Amendments to the Act in April 2013 granted the Commission formal powers to conduct market inquiries, the mechanism used for the Grocery Retail Market Inquiry published in December 2019. Further legislative changes in July 2019 strengthened its mandate regarding economic concentration and placed greater emphasis on participation by small businesses and historically disadvantaged people.
Are all supermarket chains affected by the new rules?
The restrictions apply specifically to Shoprite, Pick n Pay, and SPAR. Woolworths and Food Lover’s Market are unaffected because they did not hold exclusive lease agreements.
Keep reading