On September 16, 2026, the Supreme Court issued a ruling in case No. 521/21513/23 that sets new procedural rules for handling workplace injury claims involving foreign employers in Ukraine.
The litigation stems from an accident on September 6, 2018, during crab fishing in the Indian Ocean. According to court filings, a sailor working on a vessel flying the flag of the Republic of Latvia suffered severe injuries when a 100 kg steel grab and stopper cable broke while lifting industrial equipment.
The plaintiff said that the incident resulted in the amputation of his right hand at a hospital in Maputo, Mozambique, along with a 75% loss of working capacity.
The injured sailor subsequently filed a lawsuit in September 2023 against the Latvian shipowner in the Malinovsky District Court of Odesa.
The claim sought 100,300 USD in debt for health damage compensation as of August 5, 2023, 61,200 USD for three years of advance compensation, 1,700 USD monthly moving forward, 75,795.52 EUR for prosthetics expenses, and 20,000 USD for moral damage. Lower courts previously refused the claim due to citizenship discrepancies in documentation and disputes regarding the proper defendant.
Did You Know? The employment contract central to the dispute was concluded on June 25, 2018, months before the crab fishing accident occurred in the Indian Ocean.
Jurisdiction and Foreign Law
The Supreme Court disagreed with the lower courts and emphasized that Ukrainian courts cannot immediately decide fault or compensation without first establishing international jurisdiction. According to the ruling, courts must apply the Law of Ukraine “On Private International Law” or an international treaty of Ukraine. In the absence of a law chosen by the parties, the legislation of the state where the work was performed applies.
The high court said that lower instances failed to examine whether Ukrainian jurisdiction extended to the case under Articles 76 and 77 of the private international law statute and relevant provisions of the treaty with Latvia.
Article 8 of the Law of Ukraine "On Private International Law" dictates that establishing foreign law is the court's duty ex officio. The ruling clarified that a party’s failure to provide foreign law documents does not justify automatic claim dismissal.
Court Decisions and Annulments
The Malinovsky District Court of Odesa had previously refused the claim on March 18, 2025, pointing to a discrepancy where the plaintiff was listed as a citizen of Ukraine in his lawsuit but as a citizen of Moldova in his employment contract and accident documents. The Odesa Court of Appeal upheld the denial on January 27, 2026, altering the rationale to claim the suit targeted an improper defendant and lacked insurance payment evidence.
The Supreme Court annulled both lower court decisions on September 16, 2026. The case was sent back to the court of first instance for a new trial with instructions to properly assess the accident report, employment contract, and applicable substantive law.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did the workplace accident occur?
The accident happened on September 6, 2018, during crab fishing operations in the Indian Ocean.
What financial compensation did the sailor demand?
The lawsuit requested 100,300 USD for past health damage compensation, 61,200 USD for three years in advance, 1,700 USD monthly starting August 6, 2026, 75,795.52 EUR for prosthetics, and 20,000 USD for moral damages.
Ukraine, a country in Eastern Europe, is the second-largest in Europe after Russia, with a population of around 32 million. Its capital, Kyiv, was the centre of Kievan Rus’, the largest and most powerful realm in Europe in the 10th and 11th centuries, before its disintegration and centuries of foreign rule. Ukraine gained independence in 1991 as the Soviet Union dissolved, but its sovereignty has been repeatedly challenged, including by Russia’s 2022 invasion.
Why did the Supreme Court annul the lower court rulings?
The Supreme Court found that the lower instances failed to establish international jurisdiction and foreign law applicability under the Law of Ukraine “On Private International Law” before dismissing the claim.