Audience member Billy sat front and centre for the entire 90-minute debate on Tuesday night, telling four political leaders that nobody believes a word they say anymore.
According to News, the TAFE teacher spoke directly to Opposition Leader Jess Wilson, Premier Ben Carroll, One Nation Leader Warren Pickering, and Victorian Greens Leader Ellen Sandell to challenge them over transparency, accountability, and political perks.
“Most of the people that I’m in contact with are all stating the same thing. They finish their sentences with the same disappointment in their voice,” Billy said, as reported by News.
“They (say), you guys, politicians are all the same. Who can you trust? They’re all in it for themselves. Their pensions, their perks are the things we can only dream about. They’re so far moved from our reality, it’s ridiculous. Nobody believes a word you’re saying anymore,” Billy said.
The undecided voter then posed a two-part question to the stage, asking what specific actions the leaders would take to rebuild public trust and increase transparency and accountability. Following the exchange at the News24 and Herald Sun People’s Forum, News24 reported on a separate unscripted moment during the debate when Ms Wilson challenged Mr Carroll about his refusal to mention his predecessors, Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan.
“You can’t even say their name,” Ms Wilson challenged Premier Ben Carroll, according to News24.
“I can say their name, just like you can say Jeff Kennett’s name,” Mr Carroll replied.
“Jeff Kennett,” Ms Wilson replied.
During the forum exchange, Billy asked what specific actions the candidates would take to rebuild public trust after years of politically enforced overreach and recent controversies. He added, “And how will you increase transparency and accountability, so all Victorians … I’ve met blokes that are rusted on Labor voters who are not voting Labor anymore, rusted on Liberal voters that are not voting on Liberal anymore.”
Later in the debate, One Nation Leader Warren Pickering described the state of crime by comparing Victoria to “Gotham City” from Batman after an undecided voter said that “crime is to the s**thouse”.
Ben Carroll has represented the western suburbs seat of Niddrie since winning a 2012 by-election sparked by the resignation of former deputy premier Rob Hulls. Before entering parliament, he worked as a political adviser to premier Steve Bracks from 2000 to 2004.
He joined the Andrews cabinet in 2017 as Minister for Industry and Employment and later held the roads, public transport, and education portfolios. Carroll became premier and Labor leader in July 2026 after Jacinta Allan resigned.
“Let’s be honest, it’s terrible, and now we’re seeing vigilantes come out and get themselves in a world of trouble,” Mr Pickering said.
Keep reading