CSA

Why TOI‑561b Is Shaking Up Planetary Science

TOI‑561b, orbiting a 10‑billion‑year‑old star in the thick‑disk region of the Milky Way, challenges every textbook definition of a super‑Earth. With a mass of 3.2 M⊕, a radius of 1.45 R⊕, and a density that is lower than Earth’s despite a rocky composition, the planet forces scientists to rethink how small worlds retain atmospheres under extreme stellar bombardment.

“It’s not a super‑puff, but it is less dense than you would expect from an Earth‑like interior,” explains Dr. Johanna Teske of the Carnegie Institution for Science. This paradox sparked a multi‑institution study that combined NASA’s James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) with ground‑based spectroscopy to peer through the planet’s searing daylight.

Key numbers at a glance

• Orbital period: 0.44 days (≈10.5 hours)
• Dayside temperature (observed): ≈1,800 °C
• Expected bare‑rock temperature: ≈2,700 °C
• Stellar distance: 280.5 light‑years
• Host‑star type: G‑type thick‑disk star, 80 % Solar mass

The James Webb Space Telescope’s Game‑Changing Observations

Using JWST’s NIRSpec (Near‑Infrared Spectrograph), researchers measured the planet’s emission spectrum during secondary eclipse – the moment the planet slips behind its star. The technique, akin to that applied to the TRAPPIST‑1 system, revealed a surprisingly cool dayside, hinting at a substantial, heat‑redistributing atmosphere.

The emission spectrum (see image below) shows muted flux at wavelengths where water vapor and silicate clouds would absorb, supporting the presence of a “wet lava ball” wrapped in a volatile‑rich envelope.

Why the temperature drop matters

If TOI‑561b were a bare rock, its surface would radiate almost all the absorbed stellar energy back into space, reaching ~2,700 °C. The ~900 °C deficit can only be explained by strong atmospheric circulation that transports heat to the night side, or by reflective clouds that bounce incident starlight away. Both scenarios require a dense, volatile‑rich atmosphere—something previously thought impossible for an ultra‑hot super‑Earth.

Magma Oceans and Thick Volatile Atmospheres: What the Data Imply

Planetary models now suggest a dynamic equilibrium between a global magma ocean and an overlying atmosphere. As the searing surface vaporizes silicates and water, gases rise to form a thick envelope; simultaneously, the cooling atmosphere rains back onto the magma, pulling volatiles back into the interior.

“It’s really like a wet lava ball,” says Dr. Tim Lichtenberg of the University of Groningen. This feedback loop could maintain a stable atmosphere for billions of years, even under relentless stellar winds.

Real‑world analogues

• 55 Cnc e: Another ultra‑short period super‑Earth that shows signs of a high‑temperature atmosphere, though its composition remains debated.
• Lava worlds in our Solar System: Io’s volcanic plumes illustrate how volcanic outgassing can generate temporary atmospheres.
• Venus: Though much cooler, its dense CO₂ envelope demonstrates how a planet can trap heat and sustain surface magma.

Implications for Future Exoplanet Research

The discovery forces a paradigm shift in three key areas:

1. Atmospheric retention models must now account for magma‑atmosphere equilibria, especially for planets with surface temperatures >1,500 °C.
2. Target selection for JWST and upcoming missions (e.g., ARIEL) should include ultra‑short period super‑Earths previously dismissed as “bare rock”.
3. Chemical fingerprinting of volatile species (H₂O, CO₂, SO₂) will become a priority to decode the formation histories of thick‑disk stars and their planetary systems.

These insights also broaden the search for habitable worlds. If a planet can cling to a thick atmosphere despite scorching conditions, then more temperate planets—especially those orbiting older, metal‑poor stars—might possess unexpected atmospheric chemistry that influences their habitability.

What This Means for the Hunt for Habitable Worlds

While TOI‑561b itself is far from habitable, its atmosphere demonstrates that “volatile‑rich” is not exclusive to Earth‑like distances. Future surveys may uncover planets with moderate temperatures where a magma‑driven atmosphere supplies essential greenhouse gases, potentially extending the traditional habitable zone.

Scientists are already planning to re‑observe TOI‑561b with JWST’s MIRI instrument to probe for specific molecular signatures. Detecting water vapor or carbon monoxide would cement the magma‑atmosphere model and open new pathways for atmospheric characterization of rocky worlds.

Did you know?

FAQ – Quick Answers About TOI‑561b

• Is TOI‑561b a gas giant? No. It’s a super‑Earth with a rocky core, but it carries a dense, volatile‑rich atmosphere.
• Can a planet this close to its star keep an atmosphere? Yes, if a magma ocean continuously replenishes gases faster than they escape, creating a steady‑state atmosphere.
• What gases are likely present? Water vapor, silicate vapors, and possibly CO₂ or SO₂, inferred from the infrared absorption features.
• How was the atmosphere detected? By measuring the planet’s dayside emission spectrum during secondary eclipse with JWST’s NIRSpec.
• Will this affect the search for life? It expands the range of planetary environments to consider, showing that atmospheres can exist on worlds once thought inhospitable.

Pro tip for aspiring exoplanet hunters

Ready to dive deeper into the mysteries of ultra‑short period planets? Explore our library of articles on scorching super‑Earths or reach out with your questions.