The murder trial of Charl Kinnear saw explosive testimony on Tuesday, with allegations that a hitman linked to the Firm gang assassinated the top detective. The shooter, who was later killed himself, is central to the new evidence presented in court.
Targeted Attack and Police Failures
Kinnear, a decorated Anti-Gang Unit (AGU) detective, was shot outside his Bishop Lavis home in September 2020. The targeted attack shocked the country and raised questions about links between organised crime and possible failures within the South African Police Service (SAPS).
The high-profile trial focuses on alleged underworld figure Nafiz Modack and his co-accused. The proceedings continue to examine the circumstances of Kinnear’s death, including claims of internal lapses and police negligence.
Ipid Testimony on Security Lapses
Mario September, Deputy Provincial Head of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid), testified in the Western Cape High Court. He stated that Ipid investigated why Kinnear’s security detail was removed despite authorities being aware that he was under threat.
September noted that the investigation into the murder remains ongoing. He further testified that certain senior police officials have been identified for further scrutiny.
Identification of the Hitman
The court heard that September interviewed two inmates at Goodwood Correctional Centre on 3 June 2025 and 11 September 2025. Before questioning them about the murder, September established their identities, their information, and their gang affiliations.
According to September, these inmates identified the shooter after being shown CCTV footage of the incident. One inmate claimed to have seen the shooter in a particular vehicle on the morning of the murder.
The witnesses described the shooter as a black African male from Valhalla Park who understood Afrikaans. They noted he was known for wearing specific sporting gear and was a hitman for the 28s/The Firm Gang, allegedly led by Ralph Stanfield.
Challenges to the Evidence
State prosecutor Gregory Wolmarans challenged this version of events, arguing that the identification appeared “convenient.” Wolmarans questioned whether the inmates had prior knowledge or were possibly present at the scene.
Judge Robert Henney also questioned why this information only surfaced five years after the murder. September replied that no one had previously come forward with evidence.
September stood by his evidence, confirming that the shooter was killed months after Kinnear’s murder. This information was verified after consulting with investigating officers in the Ralph Stanfield matter.
The trial is expected to continue on Wednesday, where further details regarding these allegations may be explored.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the alleged leader of the gang linked to the hitman?
The hitman was linked to the 28s/The Firm Gang, and the alleged leader is Ralph Stanfield.
Why did Ipid investigate Charl Kinnear’s security detail?
Ipid investigated why Kinnear’s security detail was removed even though authorities were aware that he was under threat.
When were the inmate witnesses interviewed?
The two inmates at Goodwood Correctional Centre were interviewed on 3 June 2025 and 11 September 2025.
Do you believe the late emergence of witness testimony impacts the viability of high-profile organized crime trials?
