‘Star Trek’ Faces a Crossroads: Andy Weir’s Criticism and Paramount’s Future
The future of Star Trek is under scrutiny following blunt criticism from Andy Weir, author of the blockbuster Project Hail Mary and the acclaimed The Martian. Weir didn’t hold back, publicly questioning the direction of modern Star Trek series and revealing that his own pitch for a latest show was rejected by Paramount+. This comes at a pivotal moment for the franchise, with Paramount+ reportedly pausing production on new Trek projects.
A Fan’s Disappointment: Weir’s Critique of Modern Trek
Weir, a self-described Gen X fan who grew up on the original Star Trek and Lost in Space, expressed a sentiment shared by many long-time viewers. He echoed an analyst’s observation that current Star Trek shows seem disconnected from the spirit of the original series. Even as acknowledging enjoyment of Strange New Worlds and finding Lower Decks entertaining, he was less enthusiastic about other recent installments. His comments, made on the Critical Drinker podcast, were particularly pointed regarding Star Trek: Starfleet Academy, which was recently cancelled after two seasons.
The Pitch That Didn’t Fly
Adding fuel to the fire, Weir revealed he pitched his own Star Trek series to Paramount, even meeting with showrunners and executive producer Alex Kurtzman. Despite a positive personal interaction with Kurtzman, the pitch was ultimately rejected. Weir’s reaction? A candid, “But they didn’t accept my pitch so, you realize, fuck ’em.”
Paramount’s Trek Strategy: A Pause for Reflection?
The timing of Weir’s critique coincides with a significant shift in Paramount’s Star Trek strategy. For the first time in years, there are no new Trek projects currently in production, though seasons of Strange New Worlds and Starfleet Academy remain in the pipeline. This pause raises questions about the future of the franchise and the role of Alex Kurtzman, whose deal with CBS Studios is set to expire at the finish of 2026.
Kurtzman’s Future and the Search for a New Course
Paramount+ is currently in discussions with Kurtzman and his Secret Hideout production company regarding a potential renewal or extension of his deal. The outcome of these negotiations could significantly shape the direction of Star Trek in the coming years. Following criticism surrounding Starfleet Academy, Kurtzman and other executive producers released a statement emphasizing the enduring themes of hope and warning inherent in Gene Roddenberry’s original vision.
The Legacy of Roddenberry and the Challenge of Innovation
The debate surrounding Star Trek highlights the inherent challenge of revitalizing a beloved franchise. Balancing respect for the original vision with the need for innovation and appealing to new audiences is a delicate act. Roddenberry’s original series wasn’t just optimistic; it was a response to a turbulent era, warning against the dangers of intolerance and violence. Modern iterations must grapple with contemporary issues while upholding the core values of exploration, diversity, and scientific inquiry.
FAQ
Q: What did Andy Weir say about Paramount’s Star Trek shows?
A: He criticized many of the newer shows, stating they lacked the spirit of the original series and, bluntly, calling some of them “shit.”
Q: Did Andy Weir pitch a Star Trek show to Paramount?
A: Yes, he did, but it was rejected.
Q: Is Paramount+ cancelling Star Trek?
A: Not entirely. Production on new projects is paused, but existing shows like Strange New Worlds are still in production.
Q: What is Alex Kurtzman’s role in the future of Star Trek?
A: His contract with CBS Studios expires at the end of 2026, and Paramount+ is currently in talks about a renewal.
Did you know? Star Trek: The Next Generation is often credited with revitalizing the franchise in the late 1980s, demonstrating the potential for successful continuation of the original series.
Pro Tip: Engaging with online Star Trek communities and forums can provide valuable insights into fan preferences and expectations.
What are your thoughts on the current state of Star Trek? Share your opinions in the comments below!



