A traffic fine payment has led to the acquittal of Jeremy Claassen, a former Life Orientation teacher in Worcester, who was previously sentenced to life in prison for rape. The Western Cape High Court upheld his appeal against both conviction and sentencing on Wednesday, ordering his immediate release.
Details of the Case
Claassen was charged with two counts of rape, alleging penetration of a 13-year-classic Grade 8 learner without her consent on February 7 and February 12, 2020. Both alleged incidents occurred at the school, with one taking place in a classroom. He was convicted on the first count and acquitted on the second.
Claassen was incarcerated beginning May 14, 2025. During his trial, he testified that he was at court to pay a traffic fine during the time of the alleged incident, presenting a payment receipt as evidence. The initial trial court dismissed this alibi, suggesting another person could have made the payment and noting the school principal did not confirm his absence.
The Appeal and Court Findings
Judge Gayaat Da Silva-Salie, in her ruling, highlighted several discrepancies in the complainant’s testimony. These included conflicting accounts of the classroom’s occupancy and the timing of events. The judge stated that single-witness testimony “must be clear and satisfactory in all material respects” and that the initial court failed to adequately address the contradictions.
Judge Da Silva-Salie also noted that the complainant’s account of events shifted over time, initially stating the incident occurred during both breaks and later specifying the second break. The appeal argued the trial court erred in relying on the complainant’s testimony given the inherent and substantial contradictions within it.
The judge found that undue emphasis was placed on the complainant’s emotional presentation during testimony, overshadowing a thorough examination of the inconsistencies in her account.
What Happens Next
Following the court’s order, Jeremy Claassen was released from correctional facilities immediately. It is possible the complainant may pursue further legal options, though the acquittal prevents further prosecution on the same charges. The case could prompt a review of evidence evaluation protocols in similar cases.
Frequently Asked Questions
What led to Jeremy Claassen’s acquittal?
Jeremy Claassen’s acquittal was secured by a traffic fine payment receipt, which supported his alibi that he was at court during the alleged incident. The Western Cape High Court found discrepancies in the complainant’s testimony and determined the initial court failed to adequately address these contradictions.
When were the alleged incidents said to have occurred?
The alleged incidents were said to have transpired on February 7 and February 12, 2020, at a school in Worcester.
How long was Jeremy Claassen incarcerated?
Jeremy Claassen was incarcerated from May 14, 2025, until his release following the High Court’s decision on Wednesday, February 25, 2026.
How does a single piece of evidence, like a traffic fine receipt, impact the course of justice?
