A planned gubernatorial debate at the University of Southern California is facing mounting criticism and boycott calls after Democratic leaders alleged the selection criteria unfairly excluded leading candidates of color.
Controversy Surrounds Debate Selection
On Monday, Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas and Senate President Pro Tem Monique Limón, along with leaders from multiple legislative caucuses, sent a letter to USC President Beong-Soo Kim demanding the university include all leading candidates in the March 24 debate. The letter stated the current selection process resulted in the exclusion of former U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra, former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, state Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond, and former state Controller Betty Yee.
The controversy centers on a methodology that critics claim elevated San José Mayor Matt Mahan, a white candidate, despite his recent entry into the race and limited polling numbers. Concerns have also been raised regarding potential conflicts of interest, as Mike Murphy, a co-director of the USC center hosting the debate, is advising an independent expenditure committee supporting Mahan.
Donations and Debate Criteria
Further complicating the situation, USC has received “tens of millions of dollars” in donations from real estate developer Rick Caruso and his wife, both of whom are Mahan supporters. Caruso, a USC alumnus and former trustee, stated he had no conversations with debate organizers but believes all “credible candidates” should be included.
USC and its broadcast partners—KABC-TV Los Angeles and Univision—defended their decision, stating the methodology was based on “well-established metrics” of polling and fundraising and was developed without regard to any particular candidate. Despite the controversy, the four Democrats participating in the debate—Rep. Eric Swalwell, former Rep. Katie Porter, Tom Steyer, and Mahan—have all criticized the selection criteria but have not withdrawn from the event.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted the call for a boycott?
Democratic legislative leaders called for a boycott after the university’s selection criteria excluded several leading candidates of color from participating in the debate.
Who is participating in the debate on March 24?
The candidates participating in the debate are Rep. Eric Swalwell, former Rep. Katie Porter, Tom Steyer, and San José Mayor Matt Mahan.
What is the university’s defense of its selection process?
USC stated the methodology was based on “well-established metrics” of polling and fundraising and was developed without regard to any particular candidate.
As the debate approaches, it remains to be seen whether USC will respond to the demands for greater inclusivity or if voters will heed the call for a boycott, and how this situation might influence the upcoming primary election on June 2.
