Zac Gallen’s New Deal: A Sign of MLB’s Pitching Market Trends
The Arizona Diamondbacks have re-signed starting pitcher Zac Gallen to a one-year, $22.05 million deal, a move that highlights several key trends in Major League Baseball’s current market. Although seemingly a straightforward contract extension, the agreement, including $14 million in deferrals, speaks volumes about team strategies and the evolving value placed on pitching.
The Rise of One-Year Deals for Established Pitchers
Gallen’s situation – rejecting a qualifying offer only to return at the same price with deferred money – isn’t isolated. Increasingly, teams are opting for one-year deals with proven pitchers rather than committing to longer, more lucrative contracts. This approach offers flexibility, allowing teams to reassess their needs after a season and avoid being locked into potentially unfavorable long-term commitments. It also allows players to re-enter free agency after a single season, potentially capitalizing on strong performance.
This trend is driven by several factors. The volatility of pitcher performance, particularly regarding injuries, makes long-term guarantees risky. Teams are prioritizing roster flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances and capitalize on emerging talent. Deferrals, like those included in Gallen’s deal, further soften the immediate financial impact, making these deals even more appealing.
The Qualifying Offer Dilemma and Player Agency
Gallen initially rejected the qualifying offer, a tactic employed by many players seeking a longer-term deal or a higher average annual value. The fact that he ultimately returned at the same price demonstrates a degree of negotiation leverage, but also highlights the potential drawbacks of playing the qualifying offer game. Players who reject offers and don’t find a better deal risk returning to their original team under the same terms.
The qualifying offer system, designed to compensate teams for losing free agents, often creates a standoff between players and organizations. It’s a strategic element of the modern MLB landscape, influencing contract negotiations and player movement.
Performance Decline and the Value of Proven Track Records
While Gallen was a Cy Young contender in 2022 and 2023, his 2025 season saw a jump in his ERA to a career-high 4.83 and a drop in his strikeout rate. Despite this, the Diamondbacks were willing to bring him back at a significant price. This suggests that a pitcher’s established track record still carries considerable weight, even in the face of recent performance dips.
Teams often bet on a player’s ability to rebound, particularly if they have a history of success. Gallen’s previous performance likely factored heavily into the Diamondbacks’ decision, as did his overall value to the rotation. The trade of Merrill Kelly before the deadline further solidified the need to retain Gallen’s experience.
The Impact of Deferrals on MLB Contracts
The inclusion of $14 million in deferrals is a noteworthy aspect of Gallen’s contract. Deferrals allow teams to spread out payments over several years, reducing their immediate payroll obligations. This practice is becoming increasingly common, particularly for teams looking to manage their luxury tax implications.
Deferrals can be a win-win for both players and teams. Players receive the same overall contract value, while teams gain financial flexibility. However, deferrals also come with potential risks, such as the team’s financial stability over the deferral period.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a qualifying offer? A qualifying offer is an annual offer made by a team to a free agent who meets certain service time requirements. If the player rejects the offer and signs elsewhere, the signing team forfeits draft picks.
- What are deferred payments in baseball contracts? Deferred payments allow a player to receive a portion of their salary at a later date, typically after their playing career is over.
- Why are one-year contracts becoming more common? One-year contracts offer teams flexibility and allow them to reassess their pitching needs after a season.
Pro Tip: Keep an eye on teams with significant financial resources and a need for pitching. They are likely to be active in pursuing one-year deals with established starters.
Did you know? Zac Gallen ranks behind only Randy Johnson and Brandon Webb in wins for the Arizona Diamondbacks franchise.
Want to learn more about MLB contract trends? Read the full report on ESPN.
Share your thoughts on Gallen’s new deal and the future of MLB pitching contracts in the comments below!
