According to Peacock data, audiences seeking fresh viewing material can turn to an underrated lineup of hidden gems streaming on the platform, ranging from small-town sci-fi comedies to psychological crime dramas. While the service is widely known for broadcasting Bravo reality franchises and classic NBC comedies, it also houses lesser-known television series that span multiple genres and narrative styles, as outlined by streaming curators.
Resident Alien and St-Denis-Medical Lead Comedy Offerings
Syfy’s Resident Alien stars Alan Tudyk as an extraterrestrial who crash-lands on Earth, adopts the identity of a Colorado medical examiner named Harry Vanderspeigle, and plots to wipe out humanity, according to series reviews. Tudyk’s performance blends science fiction, comedy, and drama, supported by a cast that includes Sara Tomko as his best friend Asta Twelvetrees. The series completed four seasons with a definitive narrative conclusion.
In the mockumentary space, NBC’s St. Denis Medical follows an overworked Oregon hospital staff created by the team behind Superstore. The ensemble cast features Josh Lawson as trauma surgeon Bruce, David Alan Grier as veteran doctor Ron, Allison Tolman as supervising nurse Alex, and Wendi McLendon-Covey as executive director Joyce, alongside actors Kaliko Kauahi, Mekki Leeper, and Kahyun Kim.
Psychological Thrillers and Dark Comedies on Peacock
BBC One’s British crime drama River stars Stellan Skarsgård as DI John River, a London police officer who hallucinates his recently murdered partner, Stevie (Nicola Walker), alongside other deceased individuals while investigating crimes. Created by Damon Lindelof, the Peacock original series Mrs. Davis stars Betty Gilpin as Simone, a nun on a mission to destroy a benevolent artificial intelligence that has stripped humanity of free will, alongside Jake McDorman as Wiley and Andy McQueen as Jay.
Prestige Investigations and Punk Rock Narratives
Philadelphia-set drama Long Bright River stars Amanda Seyfried as beat cop Mickey Fitzpatrick, who searches for a serial killer targeting sex workers while tracking down her missing, addiction-struggling sister Kacey (Ashleigh Cummings). Based on the book by Liz Moore, the series also features John Doman and Callum Vinson, capturing the realities of the local opioid crisis.
The Channel 4 and Peacock production We Are Lady Parts follows a group of Muslim women forming a punk band in London. Created by Nida Manzoor, the cast includes Sarah Kameela Impey as lead singer Saira, Anjana Vasan as lead guitarist Amina, Juliette Motamed as Ayesha, Faith Omole as Bisma, and Lucie Shorthouse as Momtaz.
Dystopian Surveillance and Claustrophobic Mysteries
Pro Tip: When exploring hidden gems on streaming services like Peacock, check out creator filmographies—such as following Damon Lindelof from Lost to Mrs. Davis, or Nida Manzoor from Polite Society to We Are Lady Parts—to find hidden television series matching your exact taste.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some underrated shows to watch on Peacock?
Peacock hosts several lesser-known series across genres, including the sci-fi comedy Resident Alien, the hospital mockumentary St. Denis Medical, the punk rock comedy We Are Lady Parts, and the AI-focused thriller Mrs. Davis.
Who stars in the Peacock thriller Long Bright River?
Amanda Seyfried stars as Philadelphia beat cop Mickey Fitzpatrick in Long Bright River, a series adapted from the novel by Liz Moore that also features Ashleigh Cummings, John Doman, and Callum Vinson.
Is Resident Alien available to stream on Peacock?
Yes, the Syfy sci-fi comedy Resident Alien starring Alan Tudyk is available on Peacock, featuring four complete seasons.
Join the Conversation
Which of these underrated Peacock shows is already on your watchlist? Drop a comment below to share your favorites, or subscribe to our newsletter for more streaming recommendations.