Title: "Nerdrum and ‘Ytre Høyre’: A Misunderstood Marriage in VG’s Opinion Piece"
NRK's 'Familien Nerdrum'”>Odd Nerdrum, the controversial Norwegian artist, has once again found himself in the crosshairs of public debate, this time thanks to a recent opinion piece in VG by their commentator and debate chief, Hans Petter Sjøli. Titled "Now They’ve Become Mainstream," Sjøli surprisingly lumps Nerdrum, along with figures as diverse as Elon Musk and Donald Trump, into the category of "radical right" influences making waves in the West.
The catalyst for this analysis is the NRK series "The Nerdrum Family," which aired over Christmas and has sparked a heated, albeit sometimes confused, debate. Sjøli’s article, with its sensationalist title and lack of nuance, typifies the misunderstandings surrounding the series and Nerdrum’s political leanings.
Sjøli argues that Nerdrum, along with musicians like Danby Choi (known for appearing as ‘Musk’ on the Norwegian version of The Masked Singer), represent the creeping influence of the radical right. He asserts that "radical right" ideas, once marginal, have now become normalized. He even goes so far as to claim that "radical right" is "the spirit of the time."
But what exactly is the "radical right"? In Norwegian political discourse, it’s often used to tar anyone critical of modern ‘woke’ culture with the same brush, regardless of their political leanings. For instance, Bernie Sanders, a democratic socialist, has been critical of the extreme ‘woke’ culture in the US. Does that make him ‘radical right’? Hardly.
The problem with Sjøli’s argument is that it boils down to guilt by association. Because Nerdrum is critical of modern art and favours classical realism (with Rembrandt as his lodestar), Sjøli assumes he must be ‘radical right.’ But art and politics are not so easily entwined.
As Norwegian author Kaj Skagen points out, Nerdrum’s politics are more tied to a cultural conservatism that eschews both modern art and mainstream politics. Nerdrum has been critical of both left and right in Norwegian politics, suggesting a more complicated political stance than ‘radical right.’
Moreover, the idea that a penchant for classical realism automatically links one to the ‘radical right’ is a stretch. Do fans of Bach or Shakespeare suddenly become ‘radical right’ because of their tastes? Of course not.
The NRK series "The Nerdrum Family" offers a fascinating insight into Norway’s most controversial artist. But it’s essential to approach it, and any analysis of it, with a critical eye. Sjøli’s article, unfortunately, is a case study in how not to analyze complex cultural phenomena.
Instead of engaging with the nuances of Nerdrum’s art and worldview, Sjøli resorts to simplistic labels and tired rhetoric. It’s a shame, because the series offers a wealth of material for thoughtful analysis. But instead of mining that seam, Sjøli prefers to dig in the unserious ground of clickbait.
In conclusion, the debate around "The Nerdrum Family" and Nerdrum himself is far from over. But it’s crucial that we engage with it critically, recognizing the complexities of art, culture, and politics. Labels are easy, but they often obscure more than they reveal.
Worth a look