Who Will Lead Pittsburgh: Aaron Rodgers or Jalen Milroe?
The Pittsburgh Steelers are at a crucial crossroad, deliberating between signing former New York Jets QB Aaron Rodgers or drafting Alabama’s rising star Jalen Milroe in the 2025 NFL Draft. Given Rodgers’ substantial influence and experience, his potential arrival triggered speculative discussions about the team’s long-term quarterback strategy.
Why Jalen Milroe is a Prospect to Watch
Jalen Milroe, under the tutelage of Nick Saban, has demonstrated exceptional raw talent and work ethic. He’s impressed at his Pro Day, clocking a remarkable 4.37-second 40-yard dash, prompting serious interest from NFL scouts. His deep ball accuracy boasts a 95.8 grade from Pro Football Focus for throws of 40 yards or longer, marking him as a potential deep-threat playmaker for any team.
Despite spending considerable time behind Bryce Young during his early college years, Milroe seized his opportunity upon winning the starting spot in 2023. His progression mirrors that of Lamar Jackson, though analysts caution the pitfalls Jackson initially faced—especially accuracy concerns that critics cited before Jackson’s rise to stardom.
The Steelers’ Selection Strategy
If not for a pivotal trade with the Seattle Seahawks, where they exchanged their 2025 second-round pick for DK Metcalf, the Steelers might have had an easier path to drafting Milroe. However, with that opportunity potentially off the table, Pittsburgh faces a conundrum: to use their first round, 21st overall pick on Milroe or to prioritize other positional needs.
Steve Muench from The McShay Show highlights the risks associated with developing a young quarterback, suggesting Pittsburgh needs a definitive starter to begin their development cycle, comparing their situation to Baltimore’s handling of Lamar Jackson years prior.
Colin Cowherd’s Prediction Boost: Can Milroe Win the Day?
The speculation is rife; if Aaron Rodgers joins the Steelers, would he overshadow Milroe, or instead, would the team make a bold move to ensure their future? Cowherd suggests the latter, predicting a first-round pick on Milroe if Rodgers lands in Pittsburgh, updating Kirk Cousins’ storyline but with a shift to a quarterback facing new challenges.
A Bold Move Inspired by Mentorship
Kalen DeBoer, Milroe’s former coach, praised him highly, extolling his dedication and growth mindset. Such commendations from mentorship circles further bolster Milroe’s promising forecast with teams looking for players with not just talent, but a willingness to continuously improve—a standout quality that adds depth to his profile.
Pro Tip: Keep an eye on the pre-draft movements by the Steelers. The club’s front office decisions could herald significant shifts in lineups.
FAQ: Lessons from Jalen Milroe’s Journey
Q: What positives make Jalen Milroe a strong contender for the Steelers?
A: Milroe’s speed, accurate deep throws, and an evolving work ethic make him a tantalizing prospect for teams in need of a quarterback who plays big in high-pressure situations.
Q: How does Pittsburgh’s previous move for Kenny Pickett affect their potential draft choices?
A: It establishes a pattern of calculated risks in the quarterback position. The Steelers could be amenable to another high-stakes draft pick in Milroe given the right circumstances.
Q: Why is there caution advised regarding comparing Milroe to Lamar Jackson?
A: Jackson faced significant scrutiny over his accuracy soon after his entry into the league, although he later silenced his critics. Milroe will likely encounter similar skepticism and must navigate it effectively.
What’s Next for the Steelers?
While Aaron Rodgers’ future remains uncertain, the pull of a dynamic quarterback like Jalen Milroe is difficult to ignore. Observer reports from Mike Tomlin’s side suggest flexibility in their draft choices, contingent on their quarterback strategy evolving. The decision will influence not just the next season, but potentially set the tone for the next decade in Pittsburgh.
Looking Forward: As the NFL Draft approaches, keep following Steelers news to see if they take the leap for Jalen Milroe. Feel free to share your thoughts below or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest in NFL developments!
Related reading