VALHALLA, New York – A settlement exceeding $182 million has been reached in connection with the 2015 train-SUV collision in Valhalla, New York, approximately 20 miles north of New York City. The settlement will be distributed to victims and their families.
The majority of the funds will go to the families of the five passengers who died when an SUV became disabled on the train tracks, according to reports from the Journal News. One passenger is set to receive approximately $79 million, based on projected lifetime earnings. Payments to the families of the other passengers killed in the crash will range from $4 million to $35 million.
A jury determined in 2024 that Metro-North Railroad was 71% responsible for the deaths of the passengers and injuries sustained by others, and 63% responsible for the death of the SUV driver. The jury’s findings specifically cited the train engineer and the railroad’s management of the electrified third rail as contributing factors.
Andrew Maloney, representing approximately 30 injured passengers, stated that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) should have reached a resolution sooner, characterizing the 11-year legal process as unnecessarily prolonged. He also noted that identified issues with the third rail’s design remain unaddressed.
The MTA declined to comment on the specifics of the settlement but affirmed its ongoing collaboration with state and federal officials to implement “material railroad crossing safety enhancements” across its network.
The crash unfolded when the SUV, with a gate arm resting on its vehicle, continued further onto the tracks. The train, traveling at approximately 50 mph (80 kph), struck the SUV after the engineer applied the emergency brake just three seconds prior to impact. The collision caused parts of the third rail to detach, piercing the SUV’s gas tank and extending into the first car of the train.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the outcome of the jury trial?
A jury found Metro-North Railroad liable for 71% of the deaths of the passengers and injuries to others, and 63% liable for the death of the SUV driver.
How long did it take to reach a settlement?
It took 11 years to reach the settlement, a point of contention for some legal representatives involved in the case.
What has the MTA said about safety improvements?
The MTA stated it has been working with state and federal officials on “material railroad crossing safety enhancements throughout the railroad network over the last decade.”
Given the significant financial implications and the focus on third rail safety, will this settlement prompt a broader review of commuter rail infrastructure and safety protocols?
Worth a look