A report alleging an Indonesian citizen is serving in the Israeli military is prompting calls for a swift response from Jakarta. If verified, the government is expected to act without delay.
Credibility and Constitutional Principles at Stake
The situation raises significant questions about Indonesia’s foreign policy and constitutional commitments. Israel’s military campaign in Gaza has resulted in widespread devastation, civilian deaths, hunger and displacement. Israel currently faces genocide charges before the International Court of Justice, and Indonesia has repeatedly condemned these actions.
According to reports, the Israeli military includes foreign nationals from several Muslim-majority countries: Morocco (72), Turkey (112), and Uzbekistan (264). Indonesia’s constitution commits the country to opposing colonialism, and successive governments have framed support for Palestine through this principle. An Indonesian serving in a military accused of genocide is seen as a direct contradiction of this stance.
Potential Government Response
The government is expected to act on three fronts. First, verify the facts, including the individual’s citizenship status and whether dual nationality is involved. Indonesian law prohibits voluntary service in a foreign military without state approval and allows for loss of citizenship in such cases. Second, publicly state that serving in a foreign military accused of genocide contradicts Indonesia’s constitutional principles and foreign policy. Third, strengthen oversight by monitoring recruitment networks and coordinating immigration, cyber units, and law enforcement.
Officials have noted that small numbers can set precedents, as other countries now have dozens or hundreds of citizens serving in the Israeli army. Citizenship carries obligations, and states regulate conduct affecting national security and foreign relations. Serving in a foreign military engaged in active hostilities is not considered a private matter.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the immediate concern regarding the report?
The immediate concern is the potential contradiction between an Indonesian citizen serving in the Israeli military and Indonesia’s consistent support for Palestine and condemnation of Israel’s actions in Gaza.
What does Indonesian law say about citizens serving in foreign militaries?
Indonesian law prohibits voluntary service in a foreign military without state approval and allows for loss of citizenship in such cases.
What steps could the Indonesian government take?
The government could verify the facts, craft a public statement, and strengthen oversight of recruitment networks.
As Indonesia seeks to maintain its position as a consistent defender of Palestinian rights, how will it balance the obligations of citizenship with its foreign policy objectives?
