Claybourne Elder, known for his presence in HBO’s The Gilded Age, is stepping away from the screen and returning to the spotlight of his musical roots. His debut solo album, If the Stars Were Mine, released April 3 via Center Stage Records, serves as more than just a collection of tracks—it is a sonic map of a life defined by faith, identity, and the complexities of fatherhood.
For Elder, the project is an intimate exercise in vulnerability. “Every song has an emotional memory attached, so it’s a bit like being inside my head,” the Grammy-nominated actor and singer shared. The 13-track collection doesn’t just showcase his vocal range; it chronicles a personal evolution, from the constraints of being raised in the Mormon faith to the liberation of embracing his queer sexuality.
A Sonic Map of Identity and Faith
The album functions as a bridge between Elder’s professional theatrical achievements and his private milestones. While the tracklist celebrates a lengthy career in musical theater—featuring standout versions of showstoppers from West Side Story and Sunday in the Park with George—the emotional core of the record is grounded in his life as a parent and partner.
This intersection of the public and private is where the album finds its strongest resonance. Elder uses the music to explore themes of belief and the legacy left behind for the next generation, creating a narrative that he notes can “defy gender.”
Reimagining the Familiar
Beyond the Broadway staples, Elder and his band lean into unexpected reinterpretations that highlight his versatility. Whitney Houston’s high-energy “I Wanna Dance with Somebody” is transformed into a wistful acoustic ballad, shifting the song’s perspective from celebration to reflection.
The album also touches on the collective trauma of the last few years. “Lonesome Goodbye,” a track by the Tennessee-based bluegrass band The SteelDrivers, is performed as a duet with musician Rodney Bush. Elder notes that the song recalls his experience of isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic, placing the track in a “sweet spot” of emotional honesty.
This release marks a pivotal career transition. Coming nearly a year after the conclusion of his run on The Gilded Age, the album coincides with his return to the New York stage, following his involvement in the 2021 Tony-winning revival of Company.
Quick Guide: If the Stars Were Mine
- Release Date: April 3, 2026
- Label: Center Stage Records
- Format: 13-track solo debut
- Key Themes: Fatherhood, queer identity, Mormon faith, and theatrical legacy
- Notable Covers: Melody Gardot, Whitney Houston, and The SteelDrivers
How does the intersection of theatrical training and personal storytelling change the way we experience a solo album?






