Following the trade deadline, analysts question why the front office in Atlanta failed to acquire a frontline starting pitcher despite holding a commanding National League East lead and boasting a 99.7% postseason probability at FanGraphs and Baseball Prospectus.
When the July trade deadline came and went, the overarching sentiment around the Atlanta roster wasn’t just quiet relief — it was a widespread wave of FOMO. While the front office made modest additions, they left the starting rotation largely unreinforced, sparking intense debate among analysts and fans alike. The club brought in outfield help and a veteran bullpen arm, but the glaring hole at the front of the rotation remained untouched as the postseason approaches.
Modest Deadline Additions and the Rotation Question
There is no denying the front office made moves to pad the roster. Lane Thomas arrived as an upgrade over Eli White in the outfield, while Tyler Mahle joined the staff to chew up innings for a rotation that needed workload relief. Meanwhile, left-handed reliever Brent Suter bolstered the bullpen with a rubber arm designed to keep high-leverage relievers fresh.
Yet, those transactions did little to answer the most pressing question for October: Who takes the ball in Game 2 of a playoff series? Chris Sale anchors the staff brilliantly, but behind him sits a steep drop-off. The current projected top three playoff rotation candidates are Sale, Bryce Elder, and AJ Smith-Shawver, who is essentially still completing his rehab from Tommy John surgery, alongside the possibility of Spencer Schwellenbach making starts before the regular season concludes.
Pursuing Tarik Skubal, Jacob deGrom, and Logan Webb
The lack of a blockbuster starter was not for lack of trying. Braves president of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos aimed high at the top of the market. According to team reporting, pursuits included Tarik Skubal, Jacob deGrom, and Logan Webb. Each pursuit ran into immediate roadblocks.
Skubal ultimately went to the prospect-rich Dodgers. The Giants never made Webb available despite weekend speculation. A deal for deGrom proved even more complicated because it hinged on swapping large contracts. To unload the veteran hurler and the $37 million he is owed next year, the Rangers would have required a partner willing to absorb risk on contracts like Spencer Strider’s deal, which owes $66 million over the next three years while Strider works back from injury. Ultimately, deGrom was not willing to waive his no-trade clause.
The Trade Market Pivot That Never Happened
With the tier-one targets unreachable, observers questioned why the front office did not pivot to other available arms like Robbie Ray or Casey Mize. Both pitchers ultimately landed with the Padres, a team whose farm system is not rated among the game’s elite. San Diego parted with its No. 2 prospect, Kash Mayfield, and a Minor League pitcher to acquire Mize from the Tigers.
That transaction raised questions about whether Atlanta’s top-heavy prospect capital should have been deployed. The organization features three Top 100 prospects in left-hander Cam Caminiti (No. 41), outfielder Eric Hartman (No. 73), and shortstop Tate Southisene (No. 93).
“It takes two to tango.”
John Schuerholz, Hall of Fame executive
Keep reading