A baby with a rare congenital heart defect was born to a surrogate in Texas on Wednesday, following a multi-state legal battle and an emergency intervention by Texas Attorney General The Texas Tribune. The birth comes just a day after the state attorney general’s office secured a court order to ensure the newborn receives lifesaving medical treatment.
Texas Court Orders Life-Sustaining Care for Baby Born With Rare Heart Defect
The surrogate, McKenna West of Alaska, was about 20 weeks pregnant when the fetus was diagnosed with hypoplastic left heart syndrome, according to Paxton’s office. The condition is a rare and serious congenital defect in which the left side of the heart is underdeveloped, restricting normal blood flow. Treating physicians noted that surgery offers a meaningful chance of survival, though the child will live with significant lifelong disabilities.
The case drew state involvement amid a dispute between West and the intended parents from California, identified in court documents as Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed. According to legal filings, the intended parents allegedly asked West to undergo an abortion following the diagnosis and stated they would refuse consent for post-birth surgeries, potentially seeking to transfer the child to California. West subsequently traveled to Texas to seek court protection and access to experienced medical care.
Legal Intervention and Hospital Directives
Paxton intervened in a family district court in wsbt.com, arguing that gestational agreements cannot allow adults to decline necessary medical treatment for a newborn. In addition to court filings, Paxton’s office sent formal letters to UT Southwestern Medical Center and Children’s Medical Center of Dallas, reminding the facilities of their legal obligations under Texas law.
On Tuesday, a Dallas County judge issued a temporary restraining order addressing the dispute. According to the order:
- Medically indicated stabilizing and life-sustaining care must be provided to the child upon live birth.
- No person is permitted to withhold, obstruct, delay, or direct the withholding of that care.
- The child is placed in the custody of the state while the case proceeds, rather than with the surrogate.
- The child cannot be removed from the state’s jurisdiction, though transfers for medical reasons are permitted.
- A guardian ad litem was appointed to represent the newborn, referred to in court documents as baby Gabriel.
Surrogacy Scrutiny and Next Steps
The complex legal dispute involves parallel litigation in California and Texas. According to reports, Texas law does not recognize the Alaska surrogacy contract between the parties because it is not from a sister-state. State law permits intended parents in surrogacy arrangements to be recognized as legal parents before birth, a practice that recorded 657 births in Texas last year according to the Texas Department of State Health Services, even as commercial surrogacy faces increasing scrutiny from political groups.
Outside of the known heart defect, legal representatives reported that initial signs for the newborn were positive. Lincoln Wilson Davis, a lawyer representing West, and Jacqueline Ribiero, a media relations manager for the anti-abortion advocacy group Cbsnews, confirmed the birth occurred on Wednesday.
The involved parties, including West, Gilkar, and Ahmed, were previously scheduled to appear in court on Aug. 25, though it remains unclear whether the birth will prompt an earlier court date.
Keep reading