Sarah Catherine Daniels died from a rare and aggressive cancer at her home in Porth, Rhondda Cynon Taf, at age 43 following a nine-month pathology delay that reduced her chances of successful chemotherapy, according to an inquest at Pontypridd Coroners’ Court. Coroner Rachel Knight heard that the pathology department testing her ovarian mass was completely overwhelmed by post-Covid pandemic demand, leaving the health board with a testing backlog.
Pathology Department Backlog Blamed for Nine-Month Delay
Sarah first presented to her general practitioner at age 39 in October 2021 with concerning gynaecological symptoms, according to the inquest testimony. An ultrasound scan on October 21, 2021, identified a mass on one of her ovaries, leading to a referral within the Cwm Taf Morgannwg University Health Board area. Given two surgical options—a total hysterectomy triggering early menopause or a less invasive procedure—Sarah opted for the less invasive option.
In February 2022, surgeons removed the mass, which lacked the typical visual appearance of cancer. Samples were sent to pathology for testing, but the results stalled. Martin Ludlam, a biomedical scientist and former cellular pathology and mortuary service manager for the health board, told the inquest that late 2021 and 2022 brought a significant workload increase as routine appointments resumed after Covid-19 lockdowns. Ludlam stated that the department lacked sufficient capacity to manage current demand alongside the pandemic backlog, noting that by the end of 2022, outsourcing helped clear the backlog.
Treatment Impact and Terminal Diagnosis
When Sarah finally received her pathology results, she learned her condition was terminal with a 12-month life expectancy, according to written evidence from her husband, Ben Daniels. Despite the devastating prognosis, Ben told the court that his wife “never gave up” trying to fight her illness. She sought private treatment at the Christie cancer treatment centre in Manchester, which included removing her appendix, and later received follow-up care at Velindre Cancer Centre in Cardiff involving 10 rounds of chemotherapy.
Although scans initially showed the cancer had cleared, subsequent scans revealed a recurrence. Sarah struggled to maintain safe blood markers for regular chemotherapy, resulting in sporadic treatment sessions. By January 2025, her health deteriorated significantly. Dr. Kein Yim, a consultant in clinical oncology at Velindre, stated that by March 2025, her condition declined to the point where she was too frail for further chemotherapy. Sarah died at home surrounded by loved ones on April 15, 2025.
Coroner and Medical Expert Findings
Mohamed Khalifa, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology leading the gynaecological cancer multidisciplinary team for the Cwm Taf health board, testified that Sarah lost critical time between surgery and histology. He added that her Risk of Malignancy Index had been “incorrectly reassuring” to her and her family. Khalifa stated that her time of death might have differed if chemotherapy or other treatments had started sooner, calling the nine-month delay “unacceptable.”
Coroner Rachel Knight noted that initial aspects of Sarah’s care, including her GP referral and a November 10 MRI scan, occurred in appropriate timeframes. Knight stated there was low suspicion of cancer initially and that medics acted reasonably by not ordering an entire abdomen scan. However, Knight ruled that the nine-month pathology delay was unacceptable, noting that Sarah had lived with stage-four cancer since October 2021 and that the wait impacted her treatment, quality of life, and life expectancy. The medical cause of death was recorded as metastatic signet ring adenocarcinoma of the appendix. Knight recorded a narrative conclusion to reflect the full circumstances of the death and offered condolences to Sarah’s family.
Did You Know?
Frequently Asked Questions
What caused the delay in Sarah Catherine Daniels’ cancer diagnosis?
According to inquest testimony, the pathology department responsible for testing her ovarian tissue samples was completely overwhelmed by demand and a post-Covid pandemic testing backlog.
How long was the delay in receiving pathology test results?
The inquest heard there was a nine-month delay between Sarah’s surgery in February 2022 and receiving her histology results.
What was Sarah Catherine Daniels’ medical cause of death?
Her medical cause of death was recorded as metastatic signet ring adenocarcinoma of the appendix.
What conclusion did the coroner reach?
Coroner Rachel Knight recorded a narrative conclusion, ruling that while the medical cause of death was naturally occurring, the nine-month diagnostic delay reduced Sarah’s chances of successful chemotherapy and impacted her length and quality of life.
Related reading