Columbus Blue Jackets restricted free agent Adam Fantilli remains without a contract for the 2026-27 season nearly a month into the beginning of free agency. While industry consensus expects a deal to materialize, the player’s market value faces a shifting landscape shaped by recent mega-extensions signed by fellow top draft picks Leo Carlsson and Connor Bedard.
Projected Contract Value and Salary Cap Impact
Aaron Portzline of The Athletic projected a five-year extension for Fantilli carrying an average annual value between $13MM and $13.5MM during an appearance on the Jason Gregor Show. According to roster analysis, a cap hit in that range would become the highest cap hit the Blue Jackets have ever had on their roster and consume the remainder of the club’s cap space heading into the 2026-27 season. Industry observers note that while small-market fan bases often favor spending as close to the cap as they can, Columbus isn’t necessarily competitive enough to warrant that.
Comparing Production Among Top 2023 Draft Picks
Despite receiving less national media attention than his peers, Fantilli has generated offensive output nearly identical to Carlsson. According to league statistics, Fantilli has recorded 67 goals and 140 points across 213 games, compared to Carlsson’s 61 goals and 141 points in 201 contests. Securing Fantilli at a projected price point nearly $5MM less than Carlsson represents a significant organizational win for the front office, even as front-office dynamics evolve.
Did you know? Adam Fantilli was drafted after Connor Bedard and Leo Carlsson in the 2023 NHL Draft.
Restricted Free Agency Dynamics and Offer Sheets
Market comparisons between Fantilli and Carlsson carry distinct differences. Carlsson secured a five-year, $90MM ($18MM AAV) offer sheet from the Philadelphia Flyers before the Anaheim Ducks matched the terms. Fantilli remains eligible to receive an offer sheet, though no club has been bold enough to sign him to one, and no public indication suggests Fantilli is interested in signing one. Meanwhile, Bedard stated to the media that no amount of money could have dissuaded him from remaining with the Chicago Blackhawks.
Building the Future Franchise Around Fantilli
With Zach Werenski and Kirill Marchenko not expected to re-sign with Columbus after the expiration of their current deals, the Blue Jackets are positioning Fantilli as the face of the franchise. As the team’s next best player behind those two, front-office planning centers directly on locking up the young forward for the long term.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Adam Fantilli unsigned?
Fantilli remains a restricted free agent while working through contract negotiations, influenced by recent comparable extensions signed by top 2023 draft selections.
What is Fantilli’s projected contract?
According to Aaron Portzline of The Athletic, projections point toward a five-year deal with an average annual value between $13MM and $13.5MM.
How does Fantilli’s production compare to Leo Carlsson?
Fantilli has posted 140 points in 213 games, closely matching Carlsson’s 141 points in 201 games.
Join the Conversation
What kind of contract do you think the Blue Jackets should offer Adam Fantilli? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Keep reading