Health Secretary Angela Constance commissioned an independent review on Saturday after leaked documents revealed that 19 out of 31 liver and pancreatic surgery cases at NHS Grampian were avoidable deaths, according to bbc.com.
The 2022 internal report, which remained unreleased until consultant surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib made it public, detailed systemic failures in hepatobiliary care at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. Habib also said that two patients died after undergoing the wrong procedures, prompting his call for a corporate homicide police inquiry.
“Following discussion with the first minister, I am today commissioning an urgent and fully independent review of how concerns about hepatobiliary (HPB) surgery in NHS Grampian was handled, including the 2022 report into the deaths of patients who underwent HPB surgery,” Constance said, news.stv.tv reported.
Whistleblower Raises Concerns Over Decade
Dr Mohammed Habib first raised alarms regarding patient safety at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary a decade ago, notifying health board executives, ministers, and police. His repeated internal whistleblowing ultimately triggered a 2022 review by Healthcare Improvement Scotland.
That review examined 45 cases and confirmed 20 deaths, concluding that 19 were entirely preventable. Habib’s legal representative, Aamer Anwar, told news.stv.tv that the findings exposed a “catastrophic failure to act while the Grampian leadership was busy burying evidence behind complex medical jargon.”
“My thoughts are with anyone who has lost a loved one and I am acutely aware of the courage it has taken Dr Habib to come forward,” Constance said, heraldscotland.com reported.

“If any patients have questions, require advice or support they should contact the helpline established by NHS Grampian on 08085 202030.” Constance said.
Scottish Government Responds to Leaked Files
First Minister John Swinney ordered an immediate review of how government correspondence is handled after acknowledging he first saw three letters sent by Habib on Thursday. Meanwhile, Permanent Secretary officials received instructions to preserve all records pertinent to the upcoming investigation.
The Scottish government said that any evidence pointing toward potential criminality or serious professional misconduct will be referred directly to authorities immediately, rather than waiting for the final review to conclude.
“There must be confidence that the concerns raised between 2012 and 2026 were investigated properly, that the findings were acted upon appropriately and that the necessary learning took place,” said Laura Skaife-Knight, NHS Grampian chief executive, heraldscotland.com reported. She added that the board fully welcomes the independent scrutiny.
Support Teams Deployed to Aberdeen Hospital
On November 17, Health Secretary Constance appointed an external intervention support team comprised of experienced senior NHS leaders to provide intensive turnaround assistance at NHS Grampian. Healthcare Improvement Scotland must also finish an early assessment of the health board within three months.
Former Health Secretary Humza Yousaf expressed support for dramatic institutional action. “Humza supports full transparency about what happened at NHS Grampian and will co-operate fully with any review that takes place,” a spokesperson for Yousaf told 10bmnews.com.
Constance will deliver a formal statement in Holyrood on Tuesday to unveil the exact timetable and announce the independent chair for the review.
Questions Surrounding the NHS Grampian Investigation
Who will lead the independent review into NHS Grampian?
Health Secretary Angela Constance is scheduled to announce the chair and full timetable for the independent review during her statement in Holyrood on Tuesday.
What support is available for affected patients and families?
NHS Grampian established a dedicated helpline for patients and family members seeking guidance or support, which can be reached at 08085 202030.
What did the 2022 internal report uncover about surgical deaths?
The 2022 document examined 31 liver and pancreatic surgery cases at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary and determined that 19 of those deaths were avoidable.
Angela Constance, born in Blackburn, West Lothian, in 1970, worked as a social worker in the Lothians and served as a local councillor before entering Holyrood as MSP for Livingston in 2007. She has held several cabinet posts under three first ministers, including Education Secretary and Justice Secretary, and chaired the SNP before her appointment as Health Secretary in 2026.
Constance will make a statement in Holyrood on Tuesday, where she is expected to lay out the timetable and announce who will lead the review, bbc.com reported.