Attacking NATO Would Be Absurd for the Kremlin

Rusko zvyšuje tlak na evropské země, přičemž zpravodajské služby varují před možnými útoky nebo omezenou invazí na území členských států NATO, informoval server forum24.cz.

Russian Hybrid Pressure and Warnings of NATO Border Incursions

Intelligence services across Europe have raised alarms regarding mounting Russian sabotage operations and potential limited military incursions.

Further compounding these fears, Danish intelligence warned of potential military operations against a NATO state within several months, while reports surfaced regarding Russian shadow fleet vessels potentially launching drones against Spain, France, and Italy. Despite these alarming indicators, Warburg cautions that such warnings often follow a cyclical pattern where public panic and media coverage outpace actual invasion readiness, noting that Russian military bases built near Finland and Estonia have only been partially filled.

CIA Warnings of Drone Attacks Targeting Spain, France, and Italy

The U.S. Central Intelligence Agency has warned the governments of Spain, France, and Italy that Russia is preparing drone attacks launched from sea containers on ships, according to reporting by El Mundo cited by ČT24. Lithuania’s defense ministry confirmed receiving similar intelligence following a late August briefing by CIA Director John Ratcliff. Already on Thursday, pro-Kremlin views were voiced in France, where leftist candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon blamed the growing Russian threat in Europe on Ukrainian attacks deep inside Russia’s interior, while Ukraine has been defending itself against Russian armed aggression with Western assistance since 2022.

Attacking NATO Would Be Absurd for the Kremlin
Photo: ČT24

Contrasting these reports, the Italian news agency ANSA stated that Rome received no such warnings. Meanwhile, French President Emmanuel Macron responded to heightened hybrid threats on September 18 by ordering reinforced protections for key defense infrastructure. British military analyst Keir Giles told journalists that geographic distance from Russia provides no absolute security, pointing instead to nations with weaker air defenses as primary targets for Moscow’s asymmetric tactics, noting that the target will be wherever Europe is weakest, which includes Spain and Britain due to their insufficient air defense, a concept previously outlined a year ago by the Ukrainian server Defense Express regarding sea-launched drone attacks against NATO states.

Did you know? European ministers recently discussed establishing a new “emergency security mechanism” to coordinate swift responses against hybrid threats like drone incursions and cyberattacks, novinky.cz reported.

Intelligence Assessments and the Debate Over Article 5 Triggers

European intelligence chiefs, including the head of the Czech Security Information Service Michal Koudelka, warn that Russia could test alliance cohesion within months, Seznam Zprávy reported. Jan Jireš, a defense strategist interviewed by Český rozhlas Plus, emphasized that Russia already wages an ongoing campaign of sabotage and indirect attacks against NATO territory. Jireš noted that while a successful attack resulting in civilian casualties could theoretically spark discussions around Article 5 collective defense, activating the article remains a deliberate political decision rather than an automatic trigger.

Attacking NATO Would Be Absurd for the Kremlin
Photo: Seznam Zprávy

Security experts point out that deterrence relies on strategic ambiguity, leaving Moscow uncertain about where the threshold for a military response lies. Meanwhile, the European Union continues to grapple with gaps in air defense, ammunition stockpiles, and hybrid countermeasures, as highlighted during recent ministerial meetings covered by novinky.cz, where Finnish Defense Minister Antti Häkkänen stated that Europe and NATO need better coordination, more money, and joint procurement, and Swedish Defense Minister Pål Jonson responded by saying they welcome further measures against the shadow fleet, additional sanctions, further visa restrictions, and greater support for Ukraine, alongside discussions on EU defense readiness up to 2030.

CIA warns Spain and France about potential drone strikes

What specific countries received warnings regarding sea-launched drone attacks?

According to reports in El Mundo cited by ČT24, the CIA warned the governments of Spain, France, and Italy about potential drone strikes launched from container ships. However, Italy’s ANSA agency reported that Rome received no such notification.

Attacking NATO Would Be Absurd for the Kremlin
Photo: Český rozhlas Plus

When did intelligence agencies begin warning of accelerated Russian hybrid threats?

Warnings intensified significantly through late summer and September, with Danish intelligence issuing alerts in September regarding potential operations within months, and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk highlighting similar secret service warnings about drone and missile sabotage.

How does NATO’s Article 5 apply to hybrid sabotage incidents?

As noted by defense strategist Jan Jireš in coverage by Český rozhlas Plus, Article 5 is not triggered automatically by hybrid incidents or sabotage; its activation requires a deliberate political decision by member states following an attack.

What capability gaps has the European Union identified for 2030?

Assessments cited by Reuters and reported by novinky.cz indicate that the EU currently faces notable deficiencies in air and missile defense, ammunition supplies, drone technology, and overall land and maritime capabilities.