Blue Jackets Rally Past Maple Leafs for Ninth Straight Loss

Matthew Knies scored a late tying goal and Zach Werenski added the game-winner 52 seconds later as the Columbus Blue Jackets rallied for a 4-3 victory over the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The loss extends Toronto’s winless streak to nine games. The team sits at 0-8-1 in its past nine outings and has dropped 11 of its last 12 contests, according to The Globe and Mail. Fans at Scotiabank Arena voiced their frustration during the third-period collapse by chanting “Fire Hiller” toward head coach Jim Hiller, as captured by The Leafs Nation.

Knies, Werenski and Adam Fantilli each recorded a goal and an assist for the Blue Jackets. Cam Talbot stopped 23 shots for Columbus, which improved its record to 9-12-0 after losing five straight games prior to the current two-game win streak.

“Felt like we were playing well enough to be in the lead, but we weren’t and I just like the way we stuck with it,” Werenski said, according to nhl.com. “It was a big play by Knies to tie it up there and obviously it’s nice to close it out in regulation.”

Third-Period Collapse at Home

Auston Matthews, Jake McCabe and Teddy Blueger provided the scoring for Toronto, while Anthony Stolarz made 31 saves. The Maple Leafs built a 3-1 lead before surrendering three unanswered goals in the final minutes.

The defeat follows a blown three-goal lead against the Los Angeles Kings. Matthews, serving as Toronto’s captain, did not mince words after the final horn.

“It happened quick but it’s just inexcusable, it can’t happen…” Matthews told nhl.com. “It’s obviously been a really rough stretch here but tonight, we should be embarrassed. It’s not fair to the people who pay for tickets to come and watch. It’s inexcusable.”

The Blue Jackets capitalized on a late turnover by William Nylander. Knies collected the loose puck and converted from the slot against his former club.

“It was dumb play by me, so that got them going,” Nylander said, according to Sportsnet.ca.

Locker Room Reactions in Toronto

Coach Hiller addressed the costly turnover after the game. The team continues to search for answers during a winless November.

Matthew Knies and Zach Werenski scored 52 seconds apart in the third period as the Columbus Blue Jackets rallied to hand
Photo: Sportsnet.ca

“If you’re not getting one or giving us some this way, you can’t give freebies the other way,” Hiller told nhl.com. “The ledger doesn’t balance.”

Teammates defended the coach as pressure mounted from the fanbase. McCabe emphasized unity within the locker room following the defeat.

“I mean, we’re all taking heat,” McCabe told Sportsnet.ca. “That’s what happens when you lose hockey games. I got a lot of respect for Jim. I got a lot of respect for the guys in this room. We got to stick together here. That’s the only way out.”

Questions Regarding Maple Leafs Performance

How many consecutive games have the Maple Leafs failed to win?

Toronto is winless in nine straight games, posting an 0-8-1 record over that stretch according to The Globe and Mail.

Who scored the game-winning goal for Columbus?

Zach Werenski scored with 3:28 remaining in regulation to seal the 4-3 victory for the Blue Jackets, as reported by The Globe and Mail.

Jim Hiller, born in 1969 in Port Alberni, British Columbia, was drafted by the Los Angeles Kings in 1989 and played 63 NHL games with Los Angeles, Detroit, and the New York Rangers before finishing his playing career in Germany and Italy. He won the 1991 NCAA championship at Northern Michigan University and later earned WHL and CHL coach of the year honours in 2011–12 with the Tri‑City Americans.

Hiller served as an assistant coach with Detroit, Toronto, the New York Islanders, and Los Angeles, where he was promoted to interim head coach in February 2024 and made the playoffs. He was named head coach of the Maple Leafs on June 17, 2026.

What was the score when Toronto last played Columbus?

The Maple Leafs previously defeated the Blue Jackets 6-2 on Oct. 20 in Columbus, The Globe and Mail reported.