BRASÍLIA — Supreme Court (STF) Justice Alexandre de Moraes ordered search and seizure warrants on Tuesday, August 11, targeting a former Maranhão government official accused of acting as an informant for a blogger who published reports regarding the use of official vehicles by the family of Justice Flávio Dino.
According to the court decision, investigators identified Raimundo Cutrim as the source behind information published by journalist Luís Pablo Conceição Almeida of the Blog do Luís Pablo. Law enforcement executed the searches following data extractions from the blogger’s cellular phone, which federal authorities initially seized during an operation in March.
The Investigation and Financial Transactions
During Tuesday’s operation, authorities also targeted an attorney with a search warrant over allegations that he advised the blogger regarding publications about Justice Dino. The decision issued by Justice Moraes remains under seal, and the STF has not issued a formal statement when contacted by reporters.
Court records indicate that the Federal Police (PF) uncovered financial transfers from the lawyer to the blogger, prompting an inquiry into whether the payments relate to stories favoring Raimundo Cutrim’s political group. Investigators note that the attorney allegedly transferred R$ 100,000 used for purchasing a parcel of land.
Berilo Freitas, lead defense counsel for the former secretary, confirmed that court documents cite Cutrim as the journalist’s source. However, Freitas expressed bewilderment and concern over the ruling. “I won’t state that he was the source, but the decision says that,” Freitas stated, adding that investigators are focusing on the journalist, the attorney, and the source without examining the underlying allegations.
Freitas maintained that Cutrim has no connection to the targeted lawyer and denied any link between financial payments and the blogger’s work. Journalist Luís Pablo similarly stated that the identified funds bear no relation to his professional output and that he accepted no money to publish articles against Justice Dino.
Allegations of Monitoring and Official Vehicle Use
The broader inquiry examines alleged harassment directed at Justice Dino, citing unauthorized exposure of security protocols and the deployment of state mechanisms for tracking.
Starting in November, blogger Luís Pablo published claims that Justice Dino utilized a Toyota SW4 in São Luís, Maranhão, belonging to the TJ-MA fleet. According to those reports, the vehicle was acquired using funds from the Special Fund for the Security of Magistrates (Funseg-JE) and served the justice and his relatives for continuous private travel, despite being restricted to court leadership or official missions.
In March statements, Justice Dino reported that his security detail discovered an illegal monitoring operation tracking his movements in São Luís, including the publication of vehicle license plates and security personnel names. On Tuesday, Dino’s office dismissed the reports as repeated falsehoods, asserting that officials never engaged in unauthorized use of TJ-MA vehicles. Citing new developments, the office requested reinforced security measures, noting that the STF Security Secretariat provided a blindied vehicle under an existing cooperative agreement with national courts, and that even personal vehicles belonging to the family faced monitoring.
Did You Know? The case initially landed with Justice Cristiano Zanin at the STF, who identified operational parallels with the ongoing fake news inquiry before transferring the file to Justice Alexandre de Moraes.
Press Freedom Concerns Raised
The National Association of Newspapers (ANJ), represented by executive president Marcelo Rech, criticized the judicial actions. “The search and seizure based on journalistic information opens a very dangerous precedent,” Rech said, pointing to constitutional protections under Article 5, XIV, safeguarding professional source confidentiality.
In a joint statement, the ANJ, the Brazilian Association of Radio and Television Broadcasters (Abert), and the National Association of Magazine Editors (Aner) reiterated deep apprehension regarding the episode. The entities declared that judicial orders breaching source confidentiality lack constitutional backing and threaten press freedom guaranteed by the 1988 Constitution.
Background of the Target
Raimundo Cutrim, the target of Tuesday’s search warrant, has been under house arrest since the previous month following a determination by Justice Flávio Dino that also removed him from his post as secretary of legislative affairs in the Maranhão state government. That prior decision stemmed from a separate probe investigating alleged obstruction of justice tied to a homicide case in Maranhão.
Cutrim is a retired Federal Police delegate, a former three-term state deputy, and previously served in the administration of Governor Carlos Brandão. Political allies of Justice Dino, who previously governed Maranhão, are adversaries of Brandão.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted the search and seizure warrants executed on Tuesday?
Justice Alexandre de Moraes ordered the searches after investigators analyzed a seized mobile phone belonging to blogger Luís Pablo Conceição Almeida and identified Raimundo Cutrim as an alleged news source.
What specific vehicle use allegations initiated the controversy?
Blogger Luís Pablo published reports alleging that Justice Flávio Dino and his relatives used a restricted Toyota SW4 vehicle belonging to the Maranhão Court of Justice for private transportation.
How have legal representatives and press organizations responded?
Defense attorneys criticized the focus on sources rather than the original reporting, while media associations including ANJ, Abert, and Aner issued joint statements warning that breaching source confidentiality threatens constitutional press freedoms.
How will this judicial inquiry affect future investigations into institutional monitoring in Maranhão?
Worth a look