Canada Energy Regulator Wraps Powell River Export Licence Hearing

Powell River Energy Inc. wrapped up its arguments for a 30-year electricity export licence on Friday, concluding an unprecedented Canada Energy Regulator hearing in the British Columbia community.

The subsidiary of Brookfield Renewable Partners wants to send all the power generated by its two local dams to the United States. Energy from those facilities previously powered the local mill until its closure in 2021, cbc.ca reported.

“This is especially egregious because this is happening at a time when the United States has implemented targeted and malicious tariffs to purposely cripple our critical industries,” Conservative MP Aaron Gunn, Local Conservative MP, told CBC News at the hearing.

The Canada Energy Regulator said that it received more than 2,500 written submissions against the application when it was first submitted. Intervenors including the City of Powell River, the regional district, and advocacy group Energy Democracy for B.C. argued that energy produced locally should benefit residents, according to cbc.ca reporting.

Company argues 30-year contract secures financing

Powell River Energy Inc. maintained during the hearing that the 30-year contract is necessary to secure financing for facility upgrades. Those operations currently generate about $10 million in taxes and regional revenue, cbc.ca reported.

Hundreds oppose Powell River power producer's proposal to export electricity — CBC British Columbia

During the company’s final arguments, legal counsel Scott Birse said that the firm met obligations of fair market access. Birse told the hearing that B.C. Hydro was the only domestic entity interested in buying the power, but negotiations stalled over two years. “B.C. Hydro did not offer a price and terms and conditions that were competitive,” Birse said during the proceeding.

B.C. Hydro disputed those assertions during its final argument on Friday. Lawyer Michelle Casey criticized the company’s submissions, telling the regulator, “I’m talking about a record that is full of misleading, inconsistent admissions that have been filed at the start of this proceeding.” Casey added that there was a pattern of evasiveness and a lack of transparency.

Tla'amin Nation says export licence harms territory

The old mill site has been reacquired by the Tla’amin First Nation and the Cranberry Business Group, who stated they need the electricity to attract industrial tenants and restore lost jobs. However, Powell River Energy Inc. argued that the export licence would not prevent B.C. Hydro from supplying the site.

The Tla’amin Nation disagreed with that assessment, arguing that the long-term contract would adversely affect its territory and Aboriginal title rights. “For over 100 years the nation has watched their lands and resources being exploited by third parties,” said the nation’s lawyer Jennifer Griffith, as reported by cbc.ca.

Griffith also questioned whether the facilities would remain unchanged, suggesting that operating decisions shifting to an American buyer could impact local fish habitat and land. Steve Eckert, Brookfield Renewable vice-president of commercial development and energy marketing, told the Powell River Peak that the company remains committed to local contributions after operating the hydroelectric facilities for the last 25 years.

Powell River Energy Licence Questions

When will the Canada Energy Regulator decide on the export licence?

The Canada Energy Regulator typically delivers a decision on an export licence within 12 weeks following the conclusion of a hearing, according to cbc.ca.

Who intervened in the Powell River power hearings?

Intervenors included the City of Powell River, the Tla’amin Nation, the regional district, the Townsite Ratepayers Society, Energy Democracy for B.C., B.C. Hydro, and Powerex Corp., as detailed by the Powell River Peak.

Brookfield Renewable Partners traces its hydroelectric expertise to the 1890s in Brazil, where its parent Brookfield Asset Management installed the first electrical lights and tramways in São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro. The modern partnership was established in 2011 through a merger of Brookfield Renewable Power Fund and Brookfield Renewable Power Inc., and adopted its current name in 2016.

What happened to the electricity generated by the dams before the export application?

Energy from the two local dams was used to power the Powell River mill until the industrial facility shut down in 2021, cbc.ca reported.