Central Elections Committee Bars All Arab Parties from Election

Israel’s Central Elections Committee voted on Wednesday to bar all Arab-majority parties and two individual lawmakers from the October 27 general election. The disqualifications, driven by petitions from right-wing coalition figures, face anticipated appeals at Israel’s Supreme Court, which has historically overturned similar electoral bans.

Israel’s political landscape faced a severe jolt on Wednesday, September 23, when the Central Elections Committee voted to disqualify every major Arab-majority party and two prominent lawmakers from running in the upcoming general election. The sweeping bans target the United Arab List, known as Ra’am, and the Joint List, leaving Palestinian citizens of Israel—who comprise roughly one-fifth of the country’s population—facing the prospect of complete exclusion from the parliamentary ballot unless the judiciary intervenes.

Central Elections Committee Bans Ra’am and the Joint List

The panel voted 18-5 with one abstention to bar Ra’am and the Joint List from contesting the October 27 vote. The committee considered multiple petitions filed by Likud, Otzma Yehudit, and the Choosing Life Forum of bereaved families and victims of terrorism. Applicants invoked all three disqualification clauses under Section 7A of Basic Law: The Knesset: rejecting Israel as a Jewish and democratic state, inciting racism, and supporting armed struggle against Israel.

Despite the committee’s vote, the Attorney-General’s Office told the panel that the evidence against both lists fell short of the stringent legal threshold required for a ban. Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman opposed disqualifying Ra’am, stating they found insufficient proof connecting the party to support for armed struggle.

Central Elections Committee Bars All Arab Parties from Election
Photo: theyeshivaworld.com

Under Section 7A of Basic Law: The Knesset, one ground for disqualification is supporting an armed struggle by an enemy state or terrorist organization against Israel.

Representing Ra’am before the panel, Adalah attorney Suhad Bishara argued that the petitions failed to establish an unequivocal factual record. She highlighted Abbas’s condemnation of the October 7 massacre and his repeated calls for the release of hostages held in Gaza. Ra’am chairman Mansour Abbas dismissed the committee’s decision as politically motivated.

Wednesday’s decision was “political, improper, and anti-democratic,”

Mansour Abbas, Ra’am Chairman

Abbas asserted that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his allies sought to prevent the formation of the next change government by removing his party from the race. The Joint List similarly condemned the ruling, characterizing it as an attempt to disenfranchise over a million Arab Israelis and suppress voter turnout.

Individual Lawmakers Sami Abu Shehadeh and Ofer Cassif Targeted

In addition to party-wide bans, the elections committee voted to disqualify Balad leader Sami Abu Shehadeh and Hadash-associated Jewish lawmaker Ofer Cassif. The petition against Abu Shehadeh centered largely on an article he published on October 8, 2023, one day after the Hamas-led attacks, in which he described the events as an important historical event from a military, political and strategic perspective.

Central Elections Committee Bars All Arab Parties from Election
Photo: dailysabah.com

National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir pushed for Abu Shehadeh’s disqualification, arguing the statements constituted support for terrorism. Abu Shehadeh rejected that interpretation, maintaining that he has consistently opposed harming civilians. Attorney-General Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Eisman noted that while the October 8 article raised serious concerns, they stopped short of a formal recommendation for a ban, citing the Supreme Court’s narrow legal standards.

Vowing to press on with his campaign, Abu Shehadeh stated that racists are afraid of equality and that government leaders fear Arab political participation.

Historical Context and Supreme Court Scrutiny

The immediate fate of the barred parties and candidates rests with Israel’s Supreme Court. Unlike decisions regarding individual candidates, party-list bans do not automatically trigger Supreme Court scrutiny under Israeli law, prompting the affected factions to file direct appeals expected to be heard next week.

Debate: Election Committee Banning an Arab-Israeli Party

Historically, the high court has interpreted Section 7A narrowly, requiring clear, convincing, and persuasive evidence that a prohibited objective dominates a party’s platform rather than representing isolated statements. Legal experts note that the Supreme Court has overturned most previous electoral disqualifications.

Ra’am made political history in 2021 when it became the first independent Arab party to join a governing coalition, helping to oust Netanyahu from power at the time. The party recently sought to broaden its appeal by recruiting Jewish candidate Yoav Segalovitz, who served in the 2021-2022 government and was credited with security improvements in Arab communities.

Central Elections Committee Bars All Arab Parties from Election
Photo: ynetnews.com

Meanwhile, party leader Mansour Abbas addressed internal community debates surrounding his political rhetoric in a recent Arabic-language social media post. Confronted with past interview questions regarding Palestinian displacement, Abbas clarified that his willingness to adjust his terminology did not signify any retreat from the Palestinian narrative.

“The Jewishness of the state is an existing reality that was imposed on us and was not something we chose. It is the choice of the Jewish majority and not our demand.”

Mansour Abbas, Ra’am Chairman

Abbas added that Arab political factions were compelled to acknowledge Israel’s Jewish identity in practice to secure legal participation in Knesset elections. Adalah, representing the Arab parties and minority legal interests, condemned the committee’s hearings as an arbitrary and discriminatory process.

Leave a Comment