Consumer NZ Ranks NZ Retailers on Genuine Sale Clarity

Prices for 13 products across five major retailers faced tracking by Consumer NZ during a 12-week study examining promotional language.

“There may be a discount, but it’s not perhaps as good as consumers are led to believe,” Consumer NZ research lead Rebecca Styles told 1News. She said retailers risked breaching the Fair Trading Act if customers were misled.

Consumer NZ ranked five major New Zealand retailers based on how easy it is for shoppers to spot a genuine sale. Briscoes claimed the top spot because its sale prices were generally clearly cheaper than usual prices, according to 1News. The study showed that Briscoes relied on promotional wording less frequently than rivals, and costs bounced back to standard levels between sales events.

“What sets Briscoes apart from the other stores is that prices don’t fluctuate as much,” Styles told 1News. That did not mean Briscoes always offered the lowest prices. Consumer noted a Ninja air fryer tracked during the period fell to $125 at Briscoes, while the same product later dropped to $97 at Noel Leeming, 1News reported.

Farmers placed second in the rankings, though 1News reported that some of its pricing labels could leave shoppers confused. One washing machine carried a “great price” label throughout the entire 12-week tracking period, despite the price ranging from $1248 to $1669. Consumer found a similar issue with a Samsung heat-pump dryer, which carried a “great price” label at both $1399 and $1989.

At JB Hi-Fi, a Breville Barista Express coffee machine was advertised as “On Sale” at $600. Weeks later, 1News reported the same machine appeared as a “Red Hot Deal” at $698 and also $848. Consumer pointed out that these figures were below the peak tracked cost, though the tags offered buyers minimal clarity regarding the actual money being saved.

Following criticism in a comparable inquiry the previous year, 1News said that Harvey Norman scaled back its deployment of promotional tags. However, researchers still found examples where labels were attached to prices that were not necessarily the best deals available.

A handheld garment steamer was $34 cheaper when it wasn’t labelled a “hot deal”, while an air fryer was $10 cheaper when it wasn’t promoted as a “birthday deal” or “hot deal”.

Constant promotions make it difficult for shoppers to know what a product’s normal price actually is, Styles told 1News. Noel Leeming sat at the bottom of Consumer NZ’s rankings due to being “heavy-handed” with sale promises.

“It’s impossible to know which promotional label represents the biggest opportunity to save,” Styles told 1News. One example involved a Breville coffee machine advertised as a “Mega Deal” for $869, which Consumer NZ identified as the highest price recorded for the machine during the 12-week study. “The mega deal was actually a meagre deal,” Styles told 1News.

As reported by 1News, Noel Leeming boss Jason Bell pointed out that the coffee machine frequently appeared in sales and maintained that its “Mega Deal” cost remained competitive relative to other marketplace options during that timeframe.

Bell also rejected Consumer NZ’s suggestion the promotion could breach the Fair Trading Act.

“We are confident this is not a breach of the Fair Trading Act or misleading, as it was just positioned as a deal, we did not claim a specific saving,” Bell told 1News. Other retailers had not yet responded to questions from 1News.

Sales language is designed to create excitement and urgency by activating reward centres in the human brain, according to AUT marketing lecturer Dr Jessica Vredenburg.

Because consumers frequently lack awareness of standard pricing for high-value merchandise like electronics and home appliances, evaluating whether a promotion offers genuine value becomes significantly more difficult.

Consumer NZ recommends that shoppers track prices of items they want and compare prices across retailers before making a purchase. The watchdog also advises that shoppers should not assume major sales events such as Black Friday automatically offer the lowest prices of the year.

Retailer Sales Rankings and Pricing Findings

Retailer Ranking Key Finding From Consumer NZ Study
Briscoes 1 Prices regularly returned to full price between promotions with less fluctuating promotional language.
Farmers 2 A washing machine carried a “great price” label while ranging from $1248 to $1669.
JB Hi-Fi 3 A coffee machine was marked “On Sale” at $600 and later as a “Red Hot Deal” at $698 and $848.
Harvey Norman 4 A garment steamer was $34 cheaper when it lacked a “hot deal” promotional label.
Noel Leeming 5 A coffee machine advertised as a “Mega Deal” for $869 was recorded at its highest price during the study.

Retailer Pricing Label Questions Answered

Why did Consumer NZ investigate retail sale pricing?

The watchdog tracked 13 products across five major retailers over a 12-week period to examine how sale prices and promotional language were used by businesses.

How did Noel Leeming respond to the watchdog’s findings?

Noel Leeming chief executive Jason Bell rejected the suggestion that the company breached the Fair Trading Act, stating the coffee machine was simply positioned as a deal without claiming a specific saving.

Established in 1959, Consumer NZ is an independent, non-profit advocacy organisation that conducts product testing and market investigations to inform the public and advocate for stronger consumer protections. The group is well known for publishing its quarterly magazine, Consumer, and managing Powerswitch, a website that helps households compare power plans.

What advice does Consumer NZ give to shoppers?

The watchdog recommends that shoppers track prices of items they want and compare prices across retailers rather than relying solely on promotional sales pitches.