Court Upholds Whanganui Collegiate Optional Day Fee

Whanganui Collegiate can continue charging day students nearly $11,000 for access to specific property and services after a district court case was struck out at the end of October.

The court case challenged an optional fee for day students wanting access to property and services provided by the Whanganui College Board. These services are not covered by the school’s integration agreement with the government.

The district court decision followed an Ombudsman’s investigation. That inquiry concluded the practice did not appear to be unlawful.

“They’re operating a school that’s half state, half private,” Craig Sinclair told RNZ.

Sinclair brought the district court case against Whanganui Collegiate, expressing apprehension to RNZ that the two rulings paved the way for other institutions to make participation in certain activities and entry to specific facilities conditional upon fee payments.

Optional fee covers boarding access and pastoral care

The school’s website said that students who purchased access to the non-integrated facilities could use boarding houses and prep spaces during the school day. The fee also covered tutor support, pastoral care support from the health centre, housemasters, residential masters, matrons, and house supervision during timetabled breaks.

“As an Anglican school, it contributes to our faith and chaplaincy,” the school site said. “NIFfDS students participate in all Inter-House sport and cultural competitions, co-curricular activities such as the House Swimming, Athletics and Cross Country events, House Music, Tikanga and other School-wide House activities.”

Whanganui Collegiate'
Photo: rnz.co.nz

Sinclair contended that the fee should be optional because some of the activities formed part of the collegiate’s special character and took place during regular school time. He said that students who did not pay the fee were excluded from a large part of school life. Other integrated schools asked families for a donation to cover similar costs.

“The ministry at the moment have got an opinion that what Whanganui Collegiate School is offering is a very high-quality, expensive, after-school programme and that is a load of nonsense because the cross-country is during school time, the swimming sports is during school time, quite a few of these things are during school time,” Sinclair told RNZ.

Did You Know? The school’s website detailed that students who purchased access to non-integrated facilities gained entry to boarding houses, prep spaces during the school day, tutor support, pastoral care, and house supervision during timetabled breaks.

Sinclair working on appeal over free education concerns

Sinclair told RNZ he was working on an appeal. He expressed concern that the decisions would lead to the erosion of section 33 of the Education and Training Act, which ensures free education for all New Zealanders from age five until December 31 after their 19th birthday.

Guy Gifford made the Ombudsman’s complaint as a long-time campaigner against high fees and donations charged by some integrated schools. He told RNZ he was very disappointed by the result.

According to Gifford, families missed out on thousands of dollars in tax credits because the school chose to levy a fee rather than request a donation.

Whanganui collegiate sees off challenges to optional fee of
Photo: khanlist.com

“A lot of the individual parents would be happy to pay, they want to pay,” Gifford told RNZ. “They want to contribute to their children’s education and get something a bit better than the state provides but the act is designed not to let them – you must operate at the level of a state school.”

Association of Proprietors of Integrated Schools chief executive Kevin Shore informed RNZ that educational institutions of all varieties have historically possessed the ability to bill clients for specific offerings instead of soliciting financial donations.

Shore said that schools found it increasingly difficult to make ends meet, which could drive more institutions to make optional activities or services contingent on paying a fee rather than requesting a donation. He agreed that the cases set a precedent for state schools and state integrated schools alike.

“There’s no doubt this sets a precedent and it sets a precedent for state schools as well as state integrated schools,” Shore told RNZ.

Expert Insight: Kevin Shore, the head of the Association of Proprietors of Integrated Schools, said that tightening school budgets might force additional campuses to require payments for optional provisions rather than relying on voluntary contributions.

Lease Agreement Amendments

Meanwhile, the Education Ministry said that the collegiate had fixed a lease that breached education legislation. Back in April, RNZ coverage revealed that the school had been paying the Whanganui Collegiate School Foundation to rent a hockey turf, even though integrated schools were legally barred from lease agreements, a privilege reserved solely for proprietors.

The ministry reported that the school, its proprietor, and the hockey turf owner reached an agreement earlier in the year to amend the lease agreement. The proprietor leased the turf for the school’s use.

“The lease agreement is now consistent with the school’s integration agreement and legal requirements which state it is the role of the school’s proprietor to provide property, via purchase or lease, for the school to use,” the ministry said.

Court case struck out after Ombudsman investigation

The district court case challenging Whanganui Collegiate’s optional fee for day students was struck out following an Ombudsman’s investigation that concluded the practice did not appear to be unlawful.

What services does the optional fee cover?

Obtaining purchased access granted individuals admission to residential quarters, daytime study rooms, academic tutoring, medical centre welfare assistance, housemasters, residential masters, matrons, and scheduled break supervision by house staff.

Whanganui Collegiate traces its origins to 1854, when it was founded as the Native Industrial School by the Anglican Church following a land endowment from Sir George Grey. It became a boys’ school in 1878 and adopted the English public school model under headmaster Reverend Bache Wright Harvey in the 1880s, renaming to Wanganui Collegiate College in 1882.

The school relocated to its current Liverpool Street campus, officially opened in 1911, and integrated into the state system in November 2012. Its campus is registered as a category 1 historic place with Heritage New Zealand.

How has the Education Ministry responded to other issues at the school?

The ministry said that the school, its proprietor, and the hockey turf owner reached an agreement earlier this year to amend a lease agreement so that the proprietor leases the turf for the school’s use in accordance with legal requirements.