Critics: $80M Holmes Doc Avoids Facts, Favors ‘Feels

The documentary "You Can See Everything" has taken $80 million at the U.S. box office in its first weeks, The New Statesman reported.

Elizabeth Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison and ordered to pay $452 million in restitution in 2022, The New Statesman reported.

The conviction followed a trial that found her guilty on four counts of defrauding investors in Theranos, the blood-testing startup she founded.

Roughly a month before her incarceration, Holmes and her partner Billy Evans invited directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim into their home, RTE reported. Evans said on screen that Holmes had been “turned into this monster” and “nobody knows who she is.”

Fielder and Oppenheim embed with Holmes

The resulting documentary, You Can See Everything, runs nearly three hours and has taken $80 million at the U.S. box office in its first weeks, The New Statesman reported. It is widely tipped to become the first documentary nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars.

Fielder’s technique centers on extended close-ups and repeated questions about whether Holmes was lying, The Guardian reported. He does not discuss the court case or examine the evidence that secured her conviction.

“You can see everything,” Holmes promises Fielder in the film, The Guardian reported. The paper’s reviewer wrote that Fielder “duly blinkers up and blinds himself to anything concrete.”

Divergent critical reception

RTE called it “the slipperiest film of 2026” and said it “plays like a thriller” that leaves viewers “constantly trying to pin down what you’ve just watched.” The outlet noted the power dynamic among Holmes, Fielder, and Evans is “fascinating” and that Evans “does not come out of this well.”

Critics: $80M Holmes Doc Avoids Facts, Favors 'Feels
Photo: RTÉ

The New Statesman called the film “phenomenal” and “astonishing,” highlighting its commercial and critical success. The outlet traced the Holmes story through prior works including the podcast The Dropout, Alex Gibney’s documentary The Inventor, the TV drama starring Amanda Seyfried, and John Carreyrou’s book Bad Blood.

Holmes maintains innocence

“The world believes a reality about me that isn’t true,” Holmes says in the film, according to RTE. Asked what the reality is, she replies: “I know I didn’t commit any crime.”

Holmes was found guilty of defrauding investors but not guilty of defrauding patients, RTE reported. The Edison device, which she billed as “the iPod of healthcare,” was designed to run hundreds of tests from a single drop of blood. It did not work.

Film’s approach draws ethical scrutiny

The Guardian argued the film digests a “fascinating and bleak fraud case into a thin vehicle for dopey ponderings” about emotional truth. The review said Fielder appears “uninterested in facts — he’s all about the feels.”

RTE noted the film “could’ve been wrapped up quicker, and yet it never drags.” The outlet advised avoiding spoilers for the second half, which hinges on a decision by Fielder and Oppenheim as co-directors.

Oppenheim, born in 1996 in Hollywood, Florida, directed his debut feature Some Kind of Heaven as a Harvard senior thesis; Darren Aronofsky produced and The New York Times backed it as one of the paper’s first feature-length productions. It premiered at the 2020 Sundance Film Festival.

He later made the HBO documentary series Ren Faire (2024) and the documentary Spermworld (2024). In 2026 he made his narrative debut with Primetime, starring Robert Pattinson, and co-directed You Can See Everything with Nathan Fielder, which recorded the second-best opening weekend ever for a non-musical documentary.

Critics: $80M Holmes Doc Avoids Facts, Favors 'Feels
Photo: New Statesman

“It’s very complicated,” a voice says at the end of the film, according to RTE. “Never a truer word spoken.”

Documentary covers Holmes pre-prison weeks

What is You Can See Everything?

A nearly three-hour documentary co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim that follows Elizabeth Holmes in the weeks before she reported to prison, filmed inside her home with her partner Billy Evans.

What was Elizabeth Holmes convicted of?

Four counts of defrauding investors in Theranos. She was sentenced in 2022 to 11 years in prison and ordered to pay $452 million in restitution. She was not convicted of defrauding patients.

How has the film performed commercially?

It grossed $80 million at the U.S. box office in its first weeks of release and is widely tipped to be the first documentary ever nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars.

Why do critics disagree on the film?

Did you know? The Theranos story has been adapted across multiple formats: the podcast The Dropout, the documentary The Inventor by Alex Gibney, a Hulu series starring Amanda Seyfried, and John Carreyrou’s book Bad Blood, which first exposed the fraud in 2015.