Forensic researchers have identified the remains of John Pumphrey, a 13-to-15-year-old Continental Army soldier killed during the 1780 Battle of Camden in South Carolina. Genetic genealogists confirmed his identity using DNA analysis and historical records, concluding a project that began with the discovery of 14 soldiers’ remains at the battlefield in 2020.
From Unidentified Remains to John Pumphrey
For over two centuries, the identity of the young soldier known as 9B remained a mystery, buried in a shallow grave within the pine forests of Camden, South Carolina. The breakthrough came through a partnership between the South Carolina Institute of Archaeology and Anthropology (SCIAA) at the University of South Carolina, the Richland County coroner’s office, and forensic genetic genealogy firms.
While previous archaeological work at the site utilized metal buttons and other artifacts to categorize the remains, modern genomic mapping provided the definitive link. Allison Peacock, a genetic genealogist, noted that researchers utilized “three different types of DNA” alongside biographical data to confirm the soldier’s identity. As CBS News reported, this process involved cross-referencing genetic profiles with public databases to connect the remains to living descendants, including Pam Donahue, Karen Pumphrey Etchison, and Nancy Pumphrey White.
The identification process follows the standard protocols for forensic recovery in historical contexts, where biological samples are stabilized and sequenced to compare against genealogical databases. These databases often contain information from individuals who have submitted DNA for ancestry tracking, allowing researchers to build family trees that eventually intersect with the historical paper trail of military service records.
The Life and Death of a Teenage Soldier
Historical records indicate that John Pumphrey enlisted in the 7th Maryland Regiment in 1777 at the age of 13. According to LiveNOW from FOX, biological anthropologists estimated his age at the time of enlistment by examining the growth plates in his knees.
Pumphrey’s path to the South was grueling. Before his death, he served under George Washington in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. His family’s financial situation, likely impacted by the loss of their estate following the death of his father, may have influenced his decision to enlist. Allison Peacock observed that the young soldier was likely seeking to build a new life for himself before he was killed during the Battle of Camden on August 16, 1780.
The 7th Maryland Regiment, part of the Maryland Line, was a significant component of the Continental Army’s strength in the Southern Department. Enlistment records from this period show that many young men joined the ranks seeking both opportunity and a sense of duty during the revolutionary fervor. The physical toll of the march from the Mid-Atlantic to the Carolinas was substantial, often leaving soldiers malnourished and vulnerable to disease, which complicates the forensic analysis of remains centuries later.
Historical Significance of the Battle of Camden
The Battle of Camden stands as a grim chapter in the American Revolution. The site, now preserved as the Camden Battlefield and Longleaf Pine Preserve, saw more casualties than perhaps any other engagement in the war. The Post and Courier notes that of the 3,700 American soldiers who fought that day, more than 1,000 were killed or wounded. The battle was a decisive victory for the British forces, led by Lord Cornwallis, who soundly defeated the American army under Major General Horatio Gates.
Steve Smith, a research professor at the University of South Carolina’s SCIAA, emphasized that identifying these remains serves a dual purpose: honoring individual sacrifice and grounding historical abstract in reality.
“This discovery helps highlight the critical role that South Carolina played in the winning of American independence. It brings the war and the battle to a brutal reality that cannot be fully comprehended by simply reading history. It honors those soldiers that sacrificed their lives to gain American independence,” Steve Smith, via the South Carolina Institute of Archaeology and Anthropology
Commemoration and Modern Legacy
The identification of Private Pumphrey has provided closure for a family line that spans more than 20,000 living relatives today. While the remains were reburied with full military honors in 2023, the tombstone that once bore the label “Unknown” is now set to be updated. The reburial ceremony was a formal military event, reflecting the standard practice of the U.S. government to provide appropriate honors to service members regardless of the time elapsed since their deaths.
For the descendants, the discovery is profound. Pam Donahue, a fourth-great-niece of the soldier, expressed her reaction to the news:
“To find out that we do have a young man that sacrificed his life for the development of our country, it’s amazing, absolutely amazing,” Pam Donahue, via CBS News
As the nation approaches the 250th anniversary of its founding, the story of John Pumphrey serves as a reminder of the thousands of unnamed soldiers who sustained the Continental Army during its most desperate years. Researchers and family members alike view the identification not merely as a forensic success, but as “a gift to the whole country,” ensuring that a name once lost to the sandy soil of South Carolina will soon have his name carved on it. The ongoing project to identify the remaining soldiers recovered from the site continues, with SCIAA researchers working to cross-reference additional genetic data against historical muster rolls and pension records.
Find more reporting in our News section.
Worth a look