A high-fat, low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet, while popular for weight loss, may increase the risk of small intestine tumors, according to a study published in Nature by researchers at MIT. While the diet appears to protect against colon cancer, the study found that dietary fat intake—not ketone bodies—drives tumor growth in the small intestine by stimulating stem cell proliferation.
The Small Intestine Risk vs. Colon Protection
The research, led by Omer Yilmaz of the MIT Stem Cell Initiative, reveals a paradoxical effect of the ketogenic diet on the gastrointestinal tract. While previous research published in Nature in 2022 indicated that a ketogenic diet and its byproduct, the ketone body β-hydroxybutyrate (BHB), offered protection against colon cancer, the new findings show the opposite occurs in the small intestine.
In experiments using mice genetically predisposed to intestinal cancer, those on a ketogenic diet developed tumors in the small intestine at rates equal to or higher than those on a high-fat, high-calorie “obesogenic” diet. According to Yilmaz, this highlights the danger of generalizing diet-based health claims across different body tissues. What acts as a shield in the colon may act as a catalyst for abnormal growth in the small intestine.
Did you know?
The ketogenic diet was originally developed in the 1920s to treat epilepsy. Its shift toward a weight-loss and longevity tool is a more recent development in nutritional trends.
Fat Metabolism as a Driver for Tumor Growth
A critical shift in understanding these findings is the role of fat metabolism. Researchers previously suspected that ketone bodies like BHB were responsible for the diet’s health effects. However, the MIT team concluded that ketone bodies are “metabolic bystanders” in the context of tumor development.
Instead, tumor growth is fueled by how intestinal stem cells process dietary fat through a pathway known as fatty acid oxidation. This process activates proteins called PPARs, which signal stem cells to multiply rapidly. While this proliferation is a normal, healthy response when the body needs to repair an injury, excessive stem cell activity in the small intestine can lead to the formation of tumors.
Implications for Commercial Ketone Supplements
Because the observed effects—both the risk of intestinal tumors and the protection of the colon—are tied to the body’s processing of dietary fat, the researchers suggest that commercial ketone drinks or supplements will not replicate these outcomes. These products bypass the metabolic pathway of burning dietary fat, meaning they likely do not provide the same risks or benefits observed in the study.
Pro Tip: If you are considering a major dietary change, consult with a medical professional. Research into how specific diets interact with your unique genetic predispositions is ongoing, and “one-size-fits-all” nutrition remains a complex challenge for scientists.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the ketogenic diet cause cancer in humans?
This study was conducted on mice genetically predisposed to intestinal cancer. While the findings indicate a mechanism for tumor growth in the small intestine, further research is required to understand how these findings translate to human health.
Are ketone supplements safe to use?
The MIT study suggests that the risks and benefits associated with a ketogenic diet are driven by how the body processes dietary fat, not by the presence of ketone bodies. Therefore, supplements that provide ketones directly do not necessarily trigger the same metabolic pathways.
Why does the diet affect the colon and small intestine differently?
Researchers are currently investigating this question. It remains one of the most significant mysteries in gastrointestinal research, as the two areas of the gut respond to the exact same metabolic triggers in opposite ways.
Have you experimented with different dietary patterns for health? Share your experiences in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates on nutritional science and metabolic research.
Worth a look
