Egypt FA Blames Controversial VAR Decisions for World Cup Defeat to Argentina

The Disallowed Goal and VAR Protocol

The central point of contention occurred in the 58th minute of the match. Egypt scored a goal via Mostafa Ziko, but the strike was ruled out after a VAR review. According to Yahoo Sports, the review focused on contact that happened on the opposite side of the pitch approximately 20 seconds before the goal.

The technical dispute centers on the Attacking Possession Phase (APP). The New York Times reports that VAR official Jerome Brisard determined the APP began when Argentina’s Lisandro Martinez lost possession. While Martinez’s foot was stepped on by Egypt’s Marwan Attia, the analysis suggests that standing on an opponent’s foot is not inherently a foul.

The Egyptian FA argued that the failure to maintain consistency and fairness in these decisions left “profound questions” about the match’s integrity. This is not an isolated VAR controversy in the 2026 tournament; the USMNT’s Folarin Balogun also received a controversial red card following a VAR review earlier in the event.

Accusations of a ‘Fixed’ Tournament

The emotional fallout from the loss led several Egyptian figures to claim the match was engineered. Mostafa Ziko, the player denied the goal, told Yahoo Sports that the injustice was clear.

“It is clear that this tournament has been fixed. But God is sufficient for us.”
Mostafa Ziko, Egypt National Team

Ziko further elaborated on his frustration to the broadcaster TSN, stating that the “cup is directed towards Argentina.” This sentiment was echoed by manager Hossam Hassan, who suggested that external factors beyond technical play may have influenced the result to ensure the world champions and Lionel Messi remained in the competition.

Hassan’s anger extended to the logistics of the match. He criticized the 12 p.m. ET kickoff time at Atlanta Stadium, claiming that whoever schedules such matches has “never played football,” despite the stadium’s air-conditioning.

Argentina’s Late Comeback Timeline

The match was a stark reversal of fortune. Egypt held a commanding 2-0 lead until the 79th minute. Argentina’s surge happened in a rapid window of time:

• 79th Minute: Argentina scores its first goal, assisted by Lionel Messi.
• Between 79th and 84th Minute: Lionel Messi scores the second goal, cutting the lead to 2-1.
• Stoppage Time: Enzo Fernández scores a header to secure a 3-2 victory.

The winning goal by Fernández was preceded by a perceived foul in the build-up and a penalty claim by Mohamed Salah that was not awarded. According to The Guardian, the comeback was so desperate it left Messi in tears at the final whistle.

Institutional and Coaching Reactions

While the Egyptian FA used formal language in its social media statement, focusing on integrity, fairness, and transparency, coach Hossam Hassan was more blunt. Speaking to beIN Sports via France24, Hassan claimed the victory for Argentina was “undeserved.”

“We haven’t seen respect or fair play. A penalty was ruled out and a second (incident) that should have been checked for a penalty for us was not even checked by the VAR. A second goal was remarkably, for whatever reason, disallowed.”
Hossam Hassan, Egypt Manager

Hassan’s reaction was so severe that he declared he would “never watch the World Cup again” because of the perceived lack of justice in the competition.

Broader Tournament Implications

The defeat eliminates Egypt from the 2026 World Cup, while Argentina advances to face Switzerland in the next round. The clash highlights a growing tension between traditional football intuition and the rigid, often subjective, application of VAR protocols.

As the tournament progresses, the “old order” of football superpowers remains under scrutiny. While Argentina continues its run, other traditional powers have stumbled; Portugal recently confirmed the departure of Roberto Martínez after a last-16 exit. Meanwhile, nations like Morocco and Norway are attempting to redefine the global hierarchy as they push toward the semi-finals.

Find more reporting in our News section.