Elsternwick Townhouse Passes In at $950,000 After Slow Auction

by Chief Editor

Melbourne’s property market is showing a bifurcated performance, with developers snapping up development-ready sites while premium luxury estates and dated townhouses face cooling buyer sentiment. Recent auction results reveal a preliminary clearance rate of 56 per cent across 628 reported sales, according to Domain Group data from mid-June 2026. While well-located development blocks remain highly sought after, vendors of high-end mansions and secondary-market townhouses are increasingly forced to adjust price expectations to meet current buyer budgets.

Why are developers dominating the auction floor?

Developers are prioritizing land-rich properties that offer immediate potential for multi-unit projects, even in a cautious market. In Essendon, a three-bedroom bungalow on a 900-square-metre block at 70 Cooper Street sold for $1,845,000, surpassing its $1.7 million to $1.8 million guide, according to Nelson Alexander auctioneer Matthew Febey. The property attracted four active bidders, with the eventual winner planning to construct two townhouses. Agent Jason Barbara noted that the site’s development potential helped insulate it from broader market headwinds.

Did you know?

The Domain Group recorded 921 scheduled auctions for the week ending June 13, 2026. Of those, 121 properties were withdrawn before the hammer could fall, which are officially counted as unsold assets in clearance rate calculations.

How are luxury estates performing in the current market?

High-end luxury estates are experiencing a disconnect between vendor price guides and buyer willingness. A five-bedroom mansion at 37-39 Bournian Avenue in Strathmore sold for $5.3 million in post-auction negotiations, significantly below its $5.7 million to $6.2 million price guide, according to McDonald Upton agent Milo Rasinac. The property, which features gold-leaf ceilings and an ornate cinema, was passed in at $5.25 million before the vendors opted to “meet the market” at a lower price point to secure a sale.

What is driving the disparity between suburbs?

Market outcomes are currently dictated by a property’s specific appeal rather than broader suburb trends. While large development sites and “cosy,” well-located terraces are seeing competition, other segments are struggling. In Fitzroy, 183 George Street sold for $1,332,000—more than $200,000 above its reserve—due to its unique character and layout, according to Nelson Alexander agent James Pilliner. Conversely, an updated townhouse in Elsternwick at 3/33 Nepean Highway passed in at $950,000 after failing to draw buyer interest above its $1 million reserve, a result Barry Plant agent Stan Michael attributed to external economic pressures impacting buyer confidence.

Meet Matthew Febey of Nelson Alexander
Property Location Result Market Context
Essendon (70 Cooper St) $1.845M Above guide; developer interest.
Strathmore (37-39 Bournian Ave) $5.3M Below guide; passed in.
Elsternwick (3/33 Nepean Hwy) Passed In Below range; low buyer volume.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are some properties selling below their price guides?

Vendors are often setting guides based on historical highs, while buyers are reacting to current interest rates and economic uncertainty. When a property passes in, it often signals that the vendor’s reserve price exceeds what active bidders are willing to pay at that moment.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do withdrawn auctions affect clearance rates?

According to Domain Group, withdrawn auctions are treated as unsold properties. This methodology ensures that clearance rates provide a realistic snapshot of the market by preventing sellers from removing underperforming listings to artificially inflate success statistics.

What is a vendor bid?

A vendor bid is a bid made by the auctioneer on behalf of the seller to help move the bidding toward the reserve price. It does not represent an actual buyer offer and is used to signal the seller’s minimum expectations.

Pro Tip:

If you are looking to purchase in the current climate, focus on homes with “small differences”—such as superior light, smart layouts, or unique character—which continue to outperform in auctions despite broader market volatility.

Are you looking to buy or sell in Melbourne this year? Share your experiences in the comments below or subscribe to our weekly property newsletter for the latest auction insights.

You may also like

Leave a Comment