EU Leaders Reject Kallas, Form Seven-Person Delegation for Ukraine Peace Talks

The decision at an informal summit in Dublin means France, Germany, Italy, Poland, and the United Kingdom will each sit at the table alongside the heads of the European Commission and NATO, Seznam Zprávy reported.

The format emerged after EU leaders rejected the candidacy of Kaja Kallas, the bloc’s high representative for foreign policy, who was institutionally expected to lead.

“Kallas nobody likes,” an unnamed European leader told the authors of the Morning Post Europe newsletter, describing her as acting “as if she were still one of them” — a head of government — rather than in a service role. “The Russians would never accept Kallas,” one diplomat said off the record.

The seven-person delegation was proposed by European Council António Costa to break the deadlock. He defended the arrangement by noting that Ukraine itself negotiates through a group of three or four people, while the U.S. side fields two envoys: Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff. “Europe is big, different voices are heard, and Costa says it must be teamwork,” Czech Radio correspondent Zdeňka Trachtová reported from Brussels.

EU Leaders Reject Kallas, Form Seven-Person Delegation for Ukraine Peace Talks
Photo: Denik

The compromise reflects a deeper fracture. French President Emmanuel Macron, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni each insisted on a national seat to tell domestic voters their specific interests were protected, according to Seznamzpravy.

“In the final analysis it was about nothing other than Emmanuel Macron, Friedrich Merz, Donald Tusk and others being able to say: ‘I will not sit at a table where our fate is decided, but that is fine. The interests of you, French, German, Polish… citizens will be secured and protected,'” Seznam Zprávy’s commentary noted.

Seven seats, one mandate?

The immediate test is whether the group can operate with a unified mandate. Andrej Babiš, who attended a follow-up meeting of the “coalition of the willing” in Berlin on Thursday, said the number of representatives is not a problem “if they have a clear mandate and speak with one voice.”

He added that Europe must now agree with the United States on a common strategy and goals, “but it will certainly be tough negotiations,” České noviny reported.

EU Leaders Reject Kallas, Form Seven-Person Delegation for Ukraine Peace Talks
Photo: iROZHLAS

Latvian Prime Minister Evika Siliņa voiced skepticism about the process itself, arguing that Russia is not negotiating seriously. “Europe must have bigger balls and must not let Russia dictate conditions,” she said, according to Trachtová’s reporting, because Europe is larger, richer, and Russia is the aggressor losing on the battlefield.

Kushner’s prediction fulfilled

The outcome validated a blunt assessment by Kushner days earlier. “If Europe could designate one person to speak for it, that would be a greater success than forcing the Russians to include them in talks,” he said in Abu Dhabi. Instead, the Russian side will field the same two envoys — Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and presidential aide Yuri Ushakov — while the European side fragments into seven.

EU Leaders Gather IN Dublin Europe Scrambles For A Voice In Ukraine Peace Talks — Times Now World

Analysts question the mechanics. “How will information sharing from the negotiations with others and its interpretation inward to states work? And how will coordination of subsequent steps across national borders work?” Seznam Zprávy asked. The Morning Post Europe newsletter framed the moment as potentially historic: “Will November 13, 2026 go down in history as the day Europe definitively gave up its dream of becoming a global power?”

No Russian incentive to stop

Independent analysts see little prospect for a near-term settlement. Filip Nerad, a foreign-policy analyst, told Deník.cz that the chance of Russia ending the war is “not in percentages, but in permille.” He said the Kremlin benefits from the current trajectory and faces no pressure to concede while Ukraine resists and Europe supports it. “Until such demands are met, Vladimir Putin would gladly nod to ending the war.”

EU Leaders Reject Kallas, Form Seven-Person Delegation for Ukraine Peace Talks
Photo: České noviny

Russia’s maximalist demands — full control of Donbas, Ukraine’s permanent neutrality, and a NATO rollback to 1997 borders — remain unchanged. A German diplomat told Ekonomický magazín: “The Russians don’t want to negotiate, they want to win the war.” The same outlet reported that Macron stated plainly after the Abu Dhabi talks on November 10–11: “Vladimir Putin does not want to negotiate.”

Why Europe stays at the table

European participation is driven less by optimism than by fear of exclusion. “Europeans and Ukrainians are participating in this negotiating theater to show themselves as constructive toward the Americans and not to provoke Trump,” said Fredrik Wesslau of the European Council on Foreign Relations, as quoted by Ekonomický magazín. “The goal is that in case of a collapse of talks, the Americans blame the Russians — not Europe or Ukraine.”

EU Leaders Reject Kallas, Form Seven-Person Delegation for Ukraine Peace Talks
Photo: CNN Prima NEWS

A senior European diplomat added: “We need certainty that American engagement will lead to pressure on Russia, not on Ukraine.” The immediate concern is an anticipated Trump–Putin–Xi Jinping summit where European interests could be traded away without representation.

Kaja Kallas, 1977-born former prime minister of Estonia and first woman to hold that post, left the role in 2024 to become the EU’s high representative for foreign affairs and security policy and a vice-president of the European Commission.

Before leading the Estonian Reform Party from 2018 to 2024, she served as a member of the European Parliament from 2014 to 2018 and the Riigikogu in 2011–2014 and 2019–2021. A lawyer by training, she specialised in European competition law before entering politics.

Czech absence noted

The Czech Republic holds no seat in the new format. Babiš called this “a huge mistake,” noting that Prague has lacked a national security adviser for months. Vít Rakušan, leader of the Mayors and Independents party, welcomed Poland’s inclusion as a voice for the Visegrád Four.

Jan Lipavský (ODS) argued Europe must project strength because “only on that does Moscow listen.” SPD leader Tomio Okamura dismissed the entire format: “No one wants to negotiate with the EU on Ukraine, neither the USA, nor Russia, nor China.”

FAQ: Europe’s seven negotiators for Ukraine peace talks

The delegation comprises the leaders of France, Germany, Italy, Poland, and the United Kingdom, plus the presidents of the European Commission and the European Council. NATO’s secretary general is included in the format announced by António Costa in Dublin.

Why was Kaja Kallas rejected?
Multiple European leaders and diplomats told Morning Post Europe that Kallas lacked support among national capitals. Criticisms included her leadership style — described as acting like a head of government rather than a service-role diplomat — and her hardline stance on Russia, which diplomats said Moscow would never accept.

Andrej Babiš said the number is not a problem if the group has a clear mandate and speaks with one voice. However, analysts and outlets including Seznam Zprávy and Czech Radio have questioned information sharing, coordination, and unified interpretation across seven national capitals.

Analyst Filip Nerad told Deník.cz that Moscow demands full Russian control of Donbas, Ukraine’s exclusion from NATO, and a rollback of NATO to its 1997 borders. These positions have not changed.

U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have indicated Europe will have a seat at the table. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said in November he saw a positive shift in the American approach. However, the U.S. side itself negotiates as a duo, not a single envoy.