Olly Robbins, the former permanent under-secretary at the Foreign Office, is in early exploratory talks with Andy Burnham’s team regarding a potential security-related role in a prospective Downing Street operation. The discussions follow Robbins’ dismissal by Keir Starmer less than three months ago, which occurred after he overturned a recommendation from UK Security Vetting to deny clearance to Peter Mandelson.
Did You Know? Olly Robbins, who served as the UK’s Brexit negotiator and was once shortlisted for the cabinet secretary position, was dismissed from the Foreign Office in early 2025 following his handling of the vetting process for Peter Mandelson.
Why this potential appointment is controversial
The prospect of Robbins returning to a senior government role has drawn scrutiny from Labour figures due to the circumstances surrounding his departure from the Foreign Office. Robbins lost the confidence of both Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper after he bypassed security advice to clear Mandelson, who had faced concerns over his associations with Jeffrey Epstein, as well as senior figures in China, Russia, and Israel.
Expert Insight: The potential recruitment of Robbins represents a significant gamble for a prospective Burnham administration. While his supporters in the civil service argue he was effectively scapegoated for executing Downing Street’s own push to fast-track Mandelson, his return would likely reignite tensions with those in the current government who viewed his vetting decisions as a failure of institutional integrity.
What happens next for the national security role
Insiders suggest that the most likely position for Robbins would be national security adviser, a role currently held by Jonathan Powell. While Powell has received praise for his management of international conflicts and trade tensions, he has faced criticism regarding the Chagos Islands deal. Some Labour MPs have expressed concerns that the current Downing Street operation is underpowered in defence and foreign policy, potentially creating a path for a “heavyweight” like Robbins to return to the heart of government.
The path to such an appointment remains complex. Robbins is understood to be considering legal action against the government for damage to his reputation, a move that could complicate his re-entry into public service. Furthermore, any appointment would likely force a renewed focus on the unresolved questions regarding the vetting process and the “constant pressure” Robbins previously testified he faced to secure Mandelson’s placement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Olly Robbins originally dismissed?
He was sacked by Keir Starmer after it was disclosed that he overturned a UK Security Vetting recommendation to deny clearance to Peter Mandelson.
What security concerns were raised regarding Peter Mandelson?
The UK Security Vetting process raised concerns regarding Mandelson’s links to the convicted child sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, as well as his associations with senior figures in China, Russia, and Israel.
What is the proposed role for Robbins?
Sources suggest he could be appointed as the national security adviser, a senior Cabinet Office position that serves as the principal adviser to the prime minister on national security matters.
How significant is the risk to a potential new administration if it chooses to appoint a figure previously at the center of such a high-profile vetting scandal?
