US Data Grab: Is Your DNA the Price of Visa-Free Travel?
A quiet negotiation between New Zealand and the United States is sparking alarm bells over the future of personal data, particularly for Māori. As part of a requirement to maintain visa-free travel for New Zealanders, the US is seeking access to biometric data – fingerprints and faceprints – raising concerns about data sovereignty, privacy, and cultural sensitivities.
The Enhanced Border Security Partnership: What’s at Stake?
New Zealand is one of 42 countries participating in the US Visa Waiver Program, allowing citizens to visit the US for up to 90 days without a visa. To remain in the program, these countries must negotiate an Enhanced Border Security Partnership (EBSP) with the US Department of Homeland Security. This partnership could involve sharing personal information with the US government.
The core issue isn’t simply about security; it’s about control. Critics worry about the opaque process and the potential for overreach. What safeguards are in place? Where will the data be stored? And who will have access to it?
Māori Data Sovereignty: A Cultural Imperative
For Māori, the concerns run deeper. DNA, including biometric data, is considered taonga – a treasured possession with deep cultural and spiritual significance. Sharing this data isn’t simply a matter of privacy; it’s a potential violation of fundamental cultural values.
“My DNA is my whakapapa; it is not a travel perk to be traded away,” says Rotorua man Te Kawana Tapara, who launched a petition calling for public and parliamentary scrutiny of the EBSP. The concern centers on jurisdictional risk and the potential for surveillance overreach.
Dr Karaitiana Taiuru, a Māori data sovereignty expert, emphasizes that Māori data requires “culturally grounded models of protection and care.” He highlights the importance of upholding Te Tiriti o Waitangi obligations and protecting the sacredness, or tapu, of Māori biometric data.
Beyond Borders: The US Landscape of Data Collection
The concerns aren’t limited to New Zealand. Recent reports in the US reveal that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has been collecting DNA samples from individuals arrested during immigration enforcement protests. This practice, even as legal, raises questions about how the government is using this genetic data and the potential for creating a database of political activists.
The US government’s increasing appetite for biometric data, coupled with its utilize of powerful technologies like Palantir for data analysis, fuels anxieties about surveillance and potential misuse of information.
The Role of AI and Future Risks
Experts warn that the risks extend beyond current practices. As artificial intelligence (AI) technology advances, the potential for misuse of biometric data grows. Data collected today could be used in unforeseen ways tomorrow, potentially leading to discriminatory practices or violations of privacy.
Kirikowhai Mikaere of Te Kāhui Raraunga urges the government to apply existing Māori data governance models and frameworks to any considerations around the collection, storage, and use of Māori data, including biometric information.
What’s Being Done?
The New Zealand Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade acknowledges the discussions with the US but remains tight-lipped about specifics. A spokesperson stated that officials are working to clarify the US request and explain New Zealand’s legislative settings. Although, concerns remain about the lack of transparency and public consultation.
Vincent Olsen-Reeder, a data security conscious citizen, expresses frustration with the closed-door negotiations. “We should realize about what’s happening with our data and we should be able to – as voters and as citizens – see that conversation.”
FAQ
What is the Enhanced Border Security Partnership? It’s an agreement between the US and countries in the Visa Waiver Program to share data for border security purposes.
Why are Māori particularly concerned? Māori consider DNA to be taonga, a sacred treasure, and are worried about the cultural implications of sharing this data.
Is ICE collecting DNA from protesters? Yes, reports indicate ICE has been collecting DNA samples from individuals arrested during immigration enforcement protests.
What is Te Kāhui Raraunga? It’s a data-focused operational arm of the National Iwi Chairs Forum working to protect Māori data sovereignty.
What can I do? Stay informed, contact your local MP, and support organizations advocating for data privacy and Māori rights.
Did you know? The US government has been building a deportation machine powered by data from sources like IRS tax records and Medicaid records.
Pro Tip: Regularly review the privacy settings on your online accounts and consider using privacy-focused browsers and search engines.
Want to learn more about data sovereignty and digital rights? Read more on RNZ.
d, without any additional comments or text.
[/gpt3]
