The two railway employees accused in connection with the 2022 Garmisch-Partenkirchen train derailment, which resulted in five deaths and dozens of injuries, have been acquitted by the Munich II Regional Court. The decision, handed down today, concludes a closely watched case centered on questions of responsibility and preventative maintenance.
Fünf Tote, 70 Verletzte
The derailment occurred three and a half years ago in Burgrain, near Garmisch-Partenkirchen, and was attributed to deteriorated rail infrastructure. While the prosecution argued the two defendants could have prevented the tragedy, the court ultimately disagreed.
Prosecutors had sought sentences of probation – one year for the train dispatcher on charges of negligent homicide and bodily harm, and two years for the district manager. Defense attorneys had argued for complete acquittal for both men.
According to the prosecution, the district manager repeatedly delayed necessary repair work. The train dispatcher, who had a previously unblemished record, failed to act on a warning from a locomotive engineer the day before the accident regarding anomalies on the track. The court did not share the prosecution’s assessment of culpability.
Both defendants expressed deep regret over the accident during the trial, offering apologies to the victims and their families. They aligned themselves with their lawyers’ closing arguments. The district manager reiterated his sympathy and wished strength to those affected.
Frequently Asked Questions
What caused the train derailment?
The derailment was caused by deteriorated rail infrastructure, specifically marode (worn) tracks.
What charges were the defendants facing?
The train dispatcher faced charges of negligent homicide and bodily harm, while the district manager faced similar charges related to delaying necessary repair work.
What was the outcome of the trial?
Both defendants were acquitted by the Munich II Regional Court.
What happens next remains to be seen. While the criminal case is closed, civil lawsuits from victims and their families are still a possibility. Further investigation into the railway’s maintenance procedures and oversight could also be undertaken.
