Himachal Pradesh Revenue Minister Jagat Singh Negi triggered a political row in the state assembly on Wednesday by alleging that India paid Rs 2,300 crore per Rafale fighter jet instead of Rs 700 crore and that the aircraft “proved useless” during Operation Sindoor, leaving India with a “tough time” dealing with Pakistan.
The remarks, made during a debate on a BJP adjournment motion on corruption, prompted the Opposition to demand the comments be expunged from the record. Leader of the Opposition Jai Ram Thakur told NDTV the BJP has formally requested expunction and warned of escalating protests if the demand is not met. Negi has refused to apologise and stood by his statement on the Rafale’s performance.
Did You Know? The Himachal Pradesh Assembly witnessed unprecedented uproar on Thursday, forcing Deputy Speaker Sanjay Rattan — chairing the House in Speaker Kuldeep Pathania’s absence — to adjourn proceedings for 10 minutes after BJP and Congress members traded slogans, according to IANS reports carried by bhaskarlive.in and english.punjabkesari.com.
Assembly uproar forces adjournment
On Thursday, the Himachal Pradesh Assembly erupted after Thakur raised Negi’s Wednesday remarks. Rattan adjourned the House for 10 minutes as treasury and Opposition benches exchanged slogans, IANS reported. Negi responded by accusing the Opposition of undermining democracy and alleging legislators were not being allowed to speak, while also referencing questions raised in Parliament on the Rafale deal and the Galwan Valley clash, according to bhaskarlive.in.
Legislative business resumes after standoff
Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu urged the House to introduce 13 pending bills, warning the session might need a two-day extension. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Harshvardhan Chauhan backed the request.
Thakur initially insisted on continuing the adjournment motion discussion under Rule 67, noting Thursday was Private Members’ Day, but the Opposition ultimately agreed to allow the bills’ introduction first, IANS reported. All 13 bills were subsequently introduced, clearing the way for legislative proceedings in the Winter session.

BJP condemns remarks as insult to armed forces
BJP leaders protested outside the assembly, accusing Negi of insulting the armed forces. Vipin Singh Parmar said Negi likely did not realise the gravity of his statement. “We take pride in the fact that our army neutralised terrorists at the very spot where they had shattered the lives of innocent civilians,” Parmar said.
Former Congress minister Sudhir Sharma, who joined the BJP, said if Negi held such views, “he should simply leave for Lahore.” Sharma added that in Himachal Pradesh, “every third household has a member serving in the armed forces,” making the remarks “highly condemnable,” and accused Congress leaders from Delhi to Himachal of making such statements to regain political footing.
Expert Insight: The controversy highlights the political sensitivity of military operations in a state with deep military ties. With the BJP framing the remarks as an insult to the armed forces and the Congress leadership offering only a cryptic “everyone knows the reality” through Vikramaditya Singh, the episode risks becoming a flashpoint in the state’s political narrative ahead of any upcoming electoral test.
Congress leadership cautious
Public Works Minister Vikramaditya Singh declined to comment directly, saying only that “everyone knows the reality.” The restrained response suggests discomfort within the treasury benches over Negi’s allegations on both the Rafale pricing and operational performance.

Frequently Asked Questions
What did Jagat Singh Negi say in the assembly?
Negi alleged massive corruption in the Rafale deal, claiming India paid Rs 2,300 crore per aircraft instead of Rs 700 crore, and said the jets “proved useless” during Operation Sindoor, resulting in India having a “tough time” dealing with Pakistan.
Has Negi apologised for his remarks?
No. Negi has stood by his statement on the Rafale’s performance during Operation Sindoor and declined to apologise.
What action has the BJP demanded?
The BJP has formally demanded that Negi’s remarks be expunged from the assembly proceedings. Thakur warned the party would explore all options, including escalating protests, if the demand is not met.
Negi, born in 1957 in Kalpa, Kinnaur district, first entered the Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly in a 1995 by-election and has since won five terms, most recently in December 2022. He served as Deputy Speaker from March 2013 to December 2017 before joining the Council of Ministers in January 2023 as Revenue, Horticulture and Tribal Development Minister.
Keep reading