A U.S. citizen was mistakenly detained and left injured on the ground by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in Evanston, Illinois, on Sunday, September 20. The incident, which sparked a gathering of protesters, left the man with injuries to his head, neck, and teeth, according to local police and witnesses.
The confrontation occurred near Howard Street and Dodge Avenue in Evanston, Illinois, after emergency dispatchers received a call at about 9:49 a.m. reporting an argument on the street, according to the Evanston Police Department.
When local officers arrived, they discovered the man on the ground with various injuries while bystanders attempted to aid him. Police subsequently called an ambulance after the man reported trauma to his head, neck, and teeth.
Federal Operation and Conflicting Accounts of the Evanston Confrontation
Five federal agents were operating in separate vehicles across the neighborhood to track down a target resembling the man they ultimately stopped, according to an officer who spoke with an agent in an SUV at the scene. The agent wore plain clothes and a vest marked with federal law enforcement indicators and the word POLICE
.
A DHS spokesperson told CNN that ICE personnel immediately identified themselves as law enforcement and gave lawful commands when they encountered someone matching their target profile.
“The individual was given lawful commands but was not cooperative and refused to identify himself.”
DHS spokesperson, via CNN and local reports
According to Evanston police, an agent reported that the man resisted the detention attempt. The responding officer noted blood on that agent’s hands, which the federal official attributed to injuries sustained during the struggle before declining medical treatment. DHS asserted that ICE officers relied on their training and departed without further incident once the man finally provided his identification and verified his status.
Witness Accounts and Surveillance Footage Details
Eyewitnesses on Howard Street described a chaotic scene as the apprehension unfolded. Miguel Olivares told local media affiliate WLS that he watched the encounter while taking a break near a Mexican restaurant.
It looked like police vehicles until I started hearing, ‘I’m a U.S. citizen. I’m a U.S.
Miguel Olivares, restaurant worker and witness, via WLS
Olivares added that agents appeared rough with the man, pinning him to the ground in a manner that looked like one of the agents hit him in the face. After the agents released the resident upon realizing their error, bystanders rushed over to comfort him.
He was shooken up. He wasn’t really able to talk much. All he said was that he was a U.S.
Miguel Olivares, restaurant worker and witness, via WLS
Surveillance footage obtained by CNN captures two agents engaged in an upright struggle with the man before pulling him to the ground. The individuals then move outside the camera’s field of view, leaving a gap in the recording before additional drivers and bystanders arrive to film the aftermath. Local police noted that the federal agents ultimately left the area because they feared being attacked as protesters gathered.
Local Investigation and Legal Context in Illinois
Following the release of the detained resident, Evanston Police Chief met with him at a local hospital. An evidence technician documented and photographed his injuries as part of an active local investigation.
The Evanston Police Department reiterated that local officers do not coordinate with ICE or U.S. Customs and Border Protection, operating under the city’s Welcoming City Ordinance and the Illinois TRUST Act. Meanwhile, DHS defended the legal basis of the operation, pointing to federal statute.
“ICE has authority for lawful arrests where authorized under 8 USC 1357. Law enforcement officers use ‘reasonable suspicion’ to investigate immigration status and probable cause to make arrests consistent with the statute and the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.”
DHS spokesperson, via CNN
Evanston police continue to preserve available body-camera footage and interview witnesses to clarify the exact timeline and the cause of the man’s injuries.
Related reading