The six mayors of the municipalities of l’île d’Orléans sent an unequivocal message on Wednesday opposing any plan for a third link highway project to pass through the island, according to a joint press release issued by the municipal leaders.
Led by Jean Lapointe, prefect of the regional county municipality (MRC) and mayor of Saint-Jean-de-l’Île-d’Orléans, the elected officials stated that local citizens frequently voice concern over a potential inter-river link crossing the territory. The unyielding stance arrives during the ongoing provincial electoral campaign, directly challenging a proposal detailed by the Parti conservateur du Québec (PCQ) and its leader, Éric Duhaime, to route a new link via the island and Bellechasse. The PCQ plan involves building a new bridge between l’île d’Orléans and the southern shore of Québec, which would empty onto route Prévost and connect to the new north-bound island bridge currently under construction.
Mayors Unite Against PCQ Routing and Protect Heritage
Although the mayors did not name specific political parties in their initial statement, their position serves as a direct rebuttal to the conservative platform. The elected officials highlighted a unanimous motion adopted by the National Assembly in February 2025, which emphasized safeguarding the unique landscapes and heritage of l’île d’Orléans. Jean Lapointe emphasized that the island’s agricultural lands and patrimonial charm would be irrevocably sacrificed by a transit ramp proposal. Other political parties hold contrasting views, with the Coalition Avenir Québec proposing an eastern toll route via private partnership, the Parti Québécois advocating exclusively for public transit, the Liberal Party calling for more studies, and Québec Solidaire rejecting the concept entirely.
Did You Know? The Government of Québec considers the entirety of l’île d’Orléans a heritage site, underscoring its visual and cultural significance to the Capitale-Nationale region.
Industry Criticisms and Local Reaction
Beyond municipal resistance, transportation specialists and local business owners have raised logistical alarms regarding heavy truck traffic on route Prévost. Carl Beaulieu, co-founder of the On the road podcast, noted that while the route may suit standard passenger vehicles, commercial haulers operating large 53-foot trailers with four-axle configurations cannot practically navigate the narrow island corridor. François Jacques, owner of the Motel de l’île d’Orléans located directly on route Prévost, echoed these sentiments by describing the project as an unfeasible aberration that would fundamentally mar the region.
Expert Insight: Navigating regional infrastructure demands a delicate balance between commuter mobility and heritage preservation. When local municipal leadership and commercial freight operators unite in opposition, achieving genuine social acceptability for a major transit corridor becomes exceptionally difficult.
Political Fallout and Subsequent Scenarios
The unyielding rejection from the island’s mayors directly challenges assertions made by Éric Duhaime on September 11, when the PCQ leader maintained that social acceptability was merely underestimated by a vocal minority on the western side of the island. Jean Lapointe confirmed that the conservative leader never consulted local municipal authorities regarding the proposed route. In response to the unfolding debate, Québec mayor Bruno Marchand publicly called on the PCQ leader to address the unanimous pushback from the island’s leadership regarding project costs and community impact.

As the campaign proceeds toward the election, several developments could unfold:
- The Parti conservateur du Québec may choose to revise, defend, or clarify its proposed transit routing in light of the unanimous mayoral opposition.
- Local citizens and business owners could increase pressure on political candidates to formally abandon any plans involving island-based highway connections.
- Other political parties might leverage the municipal backlash to campaign against highway expansion through protected heritage zones.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the official position of the l’île d’Orléans mayors regarding a third link?
According to their joint press release, all six mayors are completely opposed to any third link proposal passing through the island, stating unequivocally, “We are against this intention.”

How does the Parti conservateur du Québec propose routing its third link project?
The PCQ proposes constructing a bridge between the island and the southern shore of Québec that feeds into route Prévost, utilizing the new north-bound bridge currently under construction.
What concerns have freight and transport representatives raised about the route?
According to industry commentators like Carl Beaulieu, route Prévost and the local infrastructure are entirely unsuitable for heavy commercial transport, such as 53-foot trailers with four-axle configurations.
What are your thoughts on balancing regional transit needs with the protection of designated heritage sites?